Nadav Naʾaman (2011), as pertinent to how we may better make sense out of the literary and archaeological remnants we have about the Exodus
Naʾaman, Nadav. "The Exodus Story: Between Historical Memory and Historiographical Composition." Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 11, no. 1 (2011): 39-69.
The Exodus Story: Between Historical Memory and Historiographical Composition, Journal of Ancient Near Eastern Religions 11 (2011), 39-69.
www.academia.edu
page 52
he Great Papyrus Harris registers many donations of serfs, cattle,
grain and oil that Ramesses III made to temples in Egypt, in particular to the temple of Amun at Heliopolis. He also donated many towns in Egypt and nine cities in Khuru (i.e., Canaan) to the temple of Amun. We should not assume that
temples of Amun were built in these nine cities (whose identity remains unknown); rather, the taxes of the cities were brought to the treasury of Amun’s temple at Heliopolis.
(I'm still looking how far east) I think so far east is Israel am I reading correctly? I only gotten as far as page 25. I highlighted grain and oil. What kind of oil is this? I recall David getting oil pour on him, and that caused him to be King? How did Oil do that? Was that the same kind of oil, what do you think about that? what is oil and what all do they do with oil?
I learned that Canaan is located in Ghuram India. However many claims the name Canaan located in Israel, how come? This caused me to wonder about people in Ghuram did they also travel to Israel and brought with the name Canaan? It's only a question. Also I'm not sure if these people in that location sail the sea - who are these sea people?
@common prophets do you know anything about these people in Ghuram India? And were they too affected by the drought that caused many tribes to leave India? Exodus means leave.
Other tribes left as well due to this drought, some however remain in India example in reference to R-M124 Gene , which claim the Karmali tribe has at 100% R-M124 Gene, remain in India, so no Exodus for the Karmali tribe.
Was it due to living east of the Yamuna River, as the Yamuna River flowed east and no longer west?
Is it only affecting tribes that lives west from the Yamuna river and due to droughts left India (Exodus) and some how it's the Yadavas tribe that shows this R-M124 Gene that also shows in the Jews. I wonder if the Benjamin tribe shows any R-M124 Gene?
@2PhiloVoid @common prophets @public hermit
touted as the Mt. Ebal Curse Inscription
Touted means: attempt to sell (something), typically by pestering people in an aggressive or bold manner.
Yes I looked up the word touted as I didn't know this word. Is this why Christians rejects Scott Stripling is due to pestering, I don't know Scott Stripling, I only heard of him as he's the first person to be shown in this book five views of exodus.
In the video you shared. Had the author James K. Hoffmeier. Is James K. Hoffmeier more accepted by Christians. Is he pestering people less? Yet he's an archeologist too. Is Jesus an archaeologist?
Jesus was missing for years, was he studying archaeology somewhere?
As a reminder I'll timestamp it
screenshot James K Hoffmeier an archeologist Christian. Do Christians accept him?
Here's video and it'll take you to James K Hoffmeier.
Login to view embedded media
50% straw in making baked bricks
I'm aware that in this video shows Mud bricks needing only 1% of straw. Due to this wondering what was this urgent need to gather lots of straw. I wonder what James K. Hoffmeier thinks about this, do you know if he ever talked about burnt bake bricks needing 50% of straw?
Login to view embedded media
Convergence of Evidences for Origins of Jews in the Indus Valley.
Here in this video showing more about R-M124 gene that the Jews has and how in tribes in India also has.
So to summarize this post.
1. Was it the reasons that the Karmali tribe lived on the east so able to drink water from the Yamuna river reasons able to not Exodus India? Compare to tribes living on the west of the Yamuna river and were dealing with droughts so then needed to Exodus? Yet I still am perplexed with this word Canaan that was used before Israel's naming, when Canaan is located in India, will you please help me with this word Canaan please? Who are these people who lived in Ghuram India (Canaan)? What treaties were made as well? In order to travel in harmony?
2. What was the reasoning for oil and how did oil communicate David as King?
3. The timing that I learned in that pdf about oil, did they also use oil for that type of communication then as well? How far east was this pdf, was it only as far as Canaan Israel? Let me look at the timing.
The Great Papyrus Harris
4. who is he Great Papyrus Harris and did oil do for him as it did for David, there I form a question.
5. How many papyrus Harris are there.
1) The Great Harris Papyrus, papyrus, 20th Dynasty, Thebes
2)The Harris Papyrus: The Mighty Deeds of Ramesses III
or is this the same papyrus harris?
Lets find out
Papyrus Harris I, the Longest Known Egyptian Papyrus
www.historyofinformation.com
Papyrus Harris I, the Longest Known Egyptian Papyrus
Circa 1186 to 1155 BCE
The Great Harris Papyrus was found in a tomb near Medinet Habu Offsite Link, across the Nile river from Luxor, Egypt. It was purchased by collector and merchant Anthony Charles Harris Offsite Link in 1855. The hieratic Offsite Link text of the papyrus consists of a list of temple endowments and a brief summary of the entire reign of king Ramesses III Offsite Link, second Pharaoh of the Twentieth dynasty
So did Harris Papyrus ever used oil the same way that King David did?
I'll ask this?
What are all the uses of oil for and how did oil communicate and shall I use my new vocabulary that I'm practicing I will and watch
perfect and prefect
To David who had oil pour on him to be shown as King was David prefect in this situation and yet perfect or not perfect?
And what about Papyrus Harris, was he prefect in this situation and had any oil pour on him to show he's King, and yet perfect or not perfect?
There you witness me using two words that has caused me lots of challenges which is the words perfect and prefect
prefect means to be born into politics so then are in charge with in that area of politics
Perfect means without error: Some people thinks Jesus without error
Due to I had perfect and prefect as the same word and meaning, I then would had asked, how come Pontius pilate is perfect as he killed perfect Jesus, people would never address this.
until this person from elsewhere online shown me it's two different words.
Perfect Prefect
Then I finally understood.
Pontius Pilate was prefect born into and so was in charge of and the Jews wanted to get rid of 'perfect Jesus without error' so used Pontius Pilate due to he was prefect born into politics and able to give orders.
It's the Jews who were afraid of Jesus who the Jews thought was acting out a prefect King, and so the Jews went to Pontius Pilate who was prefect and so could give orders. How much did Jews blend in with the Romans? Would people know the differences?
While earlier the Jews laws were influenced by the Romans, no longer passing down through the males, but must be past down through females, mention by this author Shaye D. Cohen
Cohen has two theories about how this came to be. One is that the Tannaim, the rabbis who codified the concept of matrilineal descent, were influenced by the Roman legal system of the time. According to two sources from the end of the second century CE and the beginning of the third century CE, in a marriage between two Romans, a child would receive the status of his father. In an intermarriage between a Roman and a non-Roman, a child received the citizenship status of its mother.
Why is Judaism passed down through the mother?
www.myjewishlearning.com