You think being told to keep the commandments and live or not keep them and die is not a forced decision. When you're commanded to do something by an authority figure, it's NOT voluntary.
When you are given a choice to do something, it's voluntary, whichever way you choose.
Deuteronomy 30:19, 20 has no command.
Did you read "Therefore choose life" as a command?
I'm sorry. May I suggest you read it again, and connect it with the words that precede it - " I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing."
I hope you see there is no command there. If not... it's better I keep quiet at this point.
Not really. The context of Jesus saying, "Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do", implies the character of the father manifests in the fathers children.
Yes, and how did they get the character of their father?
Objectively there is One Way in monotheism. So subjectively speaking if we have a corrupt image of god/gods in our minds, what is right and wrong becomes subjective.
What is right and wrong cannot become subjective... unless God is dead.
Do you believe God is dead, or that God determines right and wrong?
Your subjective view cannot change what is objective.
So, the law says you cannot make a U turn on an interstate highway.
You think the law is backward, and so you make a U turn on interstate highway.
How does that change the law, and you being sentence for a violation of the law?
It matters greatly. Mankind was given over to uncleanness and to reprobate minds because of subjective imagery of god/gods.
We were talking about Eve, so you need to get past Eve, before you get to sinful mankind.
Nowhere does the Bible say Eve was "given over to uncleanness and to reprobate minds because of subjective imagery of god/gods"
Yes, Adam was made without sin. It's not like God had bad breath when he breathed into Adam's nostrils and became a living soul. Adam was made from the earth and he was perfect for God's purpose, but he wasn't perfection. The second Adam, the Christ, is perfection.
I already see that, and I'm not disagreeing with you about that. I agree Adam was a corruptible soul in his innocence. The second Adam is perfection. The free will that is in Christ is not a will that thinks it has a freedom to sin, it's a will that is being set free from sin.
Unforced choice/decision? That would depend on knowledge. Doesn't knowledge and wisdom matter in the will? Doesn't the wise man make wise choices, and doesn't the fool make foolish choices? There are negative forces and positive forces.
Ah. So the fool makes a bad, or poor choice, because he does not put knowledge to good use, which is
what wisdom is.
Whereas, the wise man puts his knowledge to good use, and prospers.
Thank you very much.
The Proverbs and the book of Ecclesiastes are full of the contrast between the fool and the wise ones.
Here is one. Ecclesiastes 10:2 - A wise man’s heart inclines him to the right, but a fool’s heart to the left.
Did you notice, the scripture supports what I said earlier? It's what's in the heart - the self.
So, Adam and Eve acted foolishly... we can say they were fools, because they failed to use knowledge in a proper way.
They were enticed by their own desires. James 1:14
From your comment, you agree then, that an unforced choice/decision, is an exercising of free will. Yes?
I see Love as a positive force. For example, let's say I see someone cold or starving and I feel compassion, and I hurt with them, and I'm compelled to do something to alleviate the hurt. That doesn't happen because I choose to feel that way. It's a manifestation of the Spirit of God. Now I could choose to turn away, or I can choose to actually do something. But If I choose to turn away, it haunts me in my conscience. I don't choose to feel the guilt over how I betrayed my fellow man; I am forced to. I could have had joy and now I have misery.
By your reasoning, atheist have the manifestation of the Spirit of God.
No. It is because God made man in his image, that man has these attributes.
The difference between the atheist that does not turn away, even from a dog that is trying to cross the street in heavy traffic, is that the qualities of the fruit of God's spirit
goes beyond natural compassion, which the Bible says will become less evident in most people in the last days (2 Timothy 3:1-3).
It extends to even loving one's enemies, and not doing anything to harm them, but rather doing good to them.
Also, it allows one to...
"Never repay evil for evil to anyone.
[a]Respect what is right in the sight of all people. If possible, so far as it depends on you, be at peace with all people. Never take your own revenge, beloved, but
[b]leave room for the wrath
of God, for it is written: “Vengeance is Mine, I will repay,” says the Lord. “But if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him a drink; for in so doing you will heap burning coals on his head.” Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.
Romans 12:17-21
The atheist does not receive the spirit of God automatically. In fact, none of us do.
Here is how one receives the spirit of God.
In fact, why don't you tell me, how one receives the holy spirit.
Eve didn't know right or wrong, she trusted/believed God.
You do not believe God told Adam and Eve what was right and wrong, regarding the trees?
The serpent was the manipulator that sowed distrust through an adulterated imagery of god/gods, which caused her to experience a false hope which brought death. None of that is in your analogy.
Eve's death was her own.
Adam's death was not brought about by Eve's decision.
Adam's death came through his own willful disobedience... his unforced choice to disobey God. 1 Timothy 2:14
Not only did Adam's unwise choice result in his death. It resulted in the death of all his progeny. Romans 5:12
In fact, mankind dies, not because of Eve, but because of Adam... his unforced, unbeguiled, willful decision.
Not accurately. God never said don't 'touch' it lest you die.
You don't know that.
I don't know why you would say that. Here's what God says--> But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: FOR in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.
'For' means 'because'. Hence that's the reason.
God told them what eating from the tree would lead to.
The Bible does not say that is the reason both Adam and Eve believed it was wrong to eat from the tree.
You said, you studied semantics particular to psycholinguistics for well over forty years of my life... So I don't have to educate you in grammar.
I'd rather ask a child who is aged 13-16, and learning basic grammar.
You could do the same. if you have any young ones around.
Would you like me to give you the answers I got?
I believe God wouldn't lie. I don't believe He sets people up to fail.
That's right, but remember, what you think, and what we read, are two different things.
I don't know of any scholar that would agree with you, that reading God's statement translates to Adam and Eve's reason for not eating.
That, to me, is both grammatically incorrect, as well as... dare I say that.
D
9 And the Lord God called unto Adam, and said unto him, Where art thou?
10 And he said, I heard thy voice in the garden, and I was afraid, because I was naked; and I hid myself. <--This is why the hid
Adam hid because he was naked?
You making fun at me?
Earlier, you said, Adam and Eve were not blind, and the Bible, in Genesis 1:25 reads...
And the man and his wife were both naked, but they were not ashamed.
If Adam hid because he was naked, why did he not hide from the beginning?
Obviously, because that is not the reason he hid. He lied... just as he did, when he tried to blame God, for giving him the woman, of whom he previously exclaimed...
“At last this is bone of my bones,
And flesh of my flesh;
[t]She shall be called
[u]‘woman,’
Because
[v]she was taken out of
[w]man.” Genesis 2:23
See, how quickly Adam became like the one he sided with.
You're taking this out of context. Jesus is saying the children of the devil do what their father does.
In what way did I take it out of context?
Did the scriptures not say, "your will is to do your father’s desires"?
Did they not want to kill Jesus which was in line with their father's desire?
What did I say wrong, exactly?
Oh, I see. You are focusing on something other than what I pointed out.
The question was..
Did the angel that became Satan the Devil want to disobey God?
The Bible's answer:
John 8:44 Yes, he did.
John 8:44 -
When he [the Devil] lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies.
You are confusing two different things.
You're taking this Out of context. Paul is saying the woman should not usurp authority over the man because the man was not the one deceived. He's not saying Adam knew God was a liar.

Did you just write what I just read?
Can you clarify, did you make a mistake.
I need to know, if to continue.
Edit
I must be seeing things. I thought I read, 'He's saying Adam knew God was a liar.'
I'll get back to the rest later though. I'm doing something else right now.