SLOTKIN STUMPED! Senator Admits She's 'Not Aware' of Any 'Illegal' Orders From Trump to Military [WATCH]
- By RDKirk
- American Politics
- 71 Replies
Charitably speaking, a military lawyer's job is to explain to the commander how the commander can get his mission done legally. The lawyer doesn't say, "You can't do it," the lawyer says, "This is how to do it legally."Morally concerned? Please explain what only means that.
Without speaking charitably, that job does not necessarily involve invoking any kind of personal moral views. The morality of the matter is encoded within the applicable laws.
For instance, the Law of Armed Conflict (which includes applicable portions of the Geneva Conventions) states that US forces are prohibited from attacking a school or hospital--unless enemy forces are already using that school or hospital as an operational location. In that case, US forces may attack that school or hospital. The Law of Armed Conflict (in concert with the Geneva Conventions) places the moral fault on the forces that first began using those buildings for miltary purposes.
That particular lawyer may personally feel different. He may feel that the US should not under any circumstances attack a school or hospital. But it's not his job to transmit his own personal morality, but the morality encapsulated in the LOAC.
Using a "War on Terror" to invoke the Alien Enemies Act seems specious at best being as "Terror" is not an entity and it has no citizens, soldiers, etc. It is in the same category as the "War on Cancer" or the "War on Poverty".
Are the current White House lawyers well versed on military and international law? It seems counter-intuitive that striking a boat in international waters and killing all aboard instead of indicting them would be legal.
Depends on how they interpret the current Congressional resolutions. The president has presented his interpretation...it's up to Congress to dispute it.
Which Congress hasn't done yet.
What we think about in the peanut gallery is for us to make clear on election day.
Upvote
0