Yea
Yeah But how many janitors marry Kennedys? There is still a rigid caste system in late stage capitalist countries.
I do warehouse and janitorial work and if I lived in India, I would probably be a Dalit stuck in a caste system with thousands of years of formal structure. It would be the result of my karma and my underclass status would be deserved because of past lives I supposedly wasn’t “enlightened” to deserve better. Capitalism hasn’t discriminated against me religiously, culturally or socioeconomically. Capitalism can thrive if people have civil rights and economic opportunity. If I didn’t have a low IQ, I would probably do better in a capitalist system.
It seems like secularists can rationalize a caste system from economic data in a secular economy and equate wealth & poverty ( which is a human condition) with a structural economic disparity of a formal caste system that is based on primitive religiosity of a concept like karma. Capitalism can be good or bad depending on obvious economic and social conditions.
The case of the Dalits in holdovers from the caste system in India:
Socioeconomic status and discrimination
Discrimination against Dalits has been observed across
South Asia and among the South Asian diaspora. In 2001, the quality of life of the Dalit population in India was worse than that of the overall Indian population on metrics such as access to health care, life expectancy, education attainability, access to drinking water and housing.
[64][65][66] According to a 2007 report by
Human Rights Watch (HRW), the treatment of Dalits has been like a "hidden apartheid" and that they "endure segregation in housing, schools, and access to public services". HRW noted that
Manmohan Singh, then
Prime Minister of India, saw a parallel between the
apartheid system and untouchability.
[67] Eleanor Zelliotalso notes Singh's 2006 comment but says that, despite the obvious similarities, race prejudice and the situation of Dalits "have a different basis and perhaps a different solution".
[27] Though the Indian Constitution abolished untouchability, the oppressed status of Dalits remains a reality. In rural India, stated
Klaus Klostermaier in 2010, "they still live in secluded quarters, do the dirtiest work, and are not allowed to use the village well and other common facilities".
[68] In the same year, Zelliot noted that "In spite of much progress over the last sixty years, Dalits are still at the social and economic bottom of society."
[27]
According to the 2014 NCAER/University of Maryland survey, 27 per cent of the Indian population still practices untouchability; the figure may be higher because many people refuse to acknowledge doing so when questioned, although the methodology of the survey was also criticised for potentially inflating the figure.
[69] Across India, Untouchability was practised among 52 per cent of
Brahmins, 33 per cent of Other Backward Classes and 24 per cent of non-Brahmin
forward castes.
[70] Untouchability was also practised by people of minority religions – 23 per cent of Sikhs, 18 per cent of Muslims and 5 per cent of Christians.
[71]According to statewide data, Untouchability is most commonly practised in Madhya Pradesh (53 per cent), followed by
Himachal Pradesh (50 per cent), Chhattisgarh (48 per cent),
Rajasthan and Bihar (47 per cent), Uttar Pradesh (43 per cent), and
Uttarakhand (40 per cent).
[72]
en.wikipedia.org
Ecclesiastes 12:1-14, Romans 13:1-14