Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
No one is hurt by the Charismatic Movement itself any more than in any other church. It is usually the lunatic fringe that bring churches into disrepute and just as many are turned away from the faith in non-Charimatic churches as well, usually through legalism, criticism, or just plain boredom through liberalist Christless preaching.How were people hurt by the charismatic movement? Can you expand on that "hurt" you alluded to?
If the truth was known, it wasn't the church that hurt you or others, it was some people in it whose standard of holiness and love were not what they should be. A wise and godly pastor told me once that God does everything exactly right, but we have to forgive some of his servants sometimes.You'd have to ask them...
I, for instance, was hurt by an International House of Prayer wannabe that I was involved in an internship with. I was forced to go through a spiritual warfare/deliverance thing that I did not want to go through as I felt I didn't need to be delivered of anything. It ended up causing a lot of hurt and damage spiritually and was a catalyst in me stepping away from the faith for a time. That's just me though and while I no longer hold any bitterness in my heart, it was from a movement that strikes me as very similar to what I observe out of Bethel.
Ultimately, I was saying that a lot of the criticism I see towards Bethel seems to be coming from life-time cessationists or folks who were hurt by their Charismatic churches (as in folks who believe in the gifts being for today) and have since left and became cessationist.
I have done my share of treating the Bethel church as being heretical, but the Holy Spirit asked me yesterday, "Did you know that there are genuine believers there who love Jesus and have their faith in what He did for them on the Cross? Are you going to condemn the godly with those who are in error?"He went on to show me that Paul encouraged the Corinthians even though there were major issues in that church. Paul supported that church because of the true believers there who were not involved in the issues that he needed to sort out.
In that way the Holy Spirit told me not to judge Bethel church on the basis of its lunatic practices or its unconventional teaching but on the foundation of the true godly believers there who are holding up a standard for Jesus in that church.
So we deal with the issues and not put a blanket condemnation on the whole church, otherwise we could harm the faith of the godly folk in that church, who should not be the victims of collateral damage through friendly fire in the process of our heresy hunting.
If the truth was known, it wasn't the church that hurt you or others, it was some people in it whose standard of holiness and love were not what they should be. A wise and godly pastor told me once that God does everything exactly right, but we have to forgive some of his servants sometimes.
It is sobering when we consider that God measures our love for Christ on our willingness to totally forgive those who have hurt us the most.
But not the whole Pentecostal/Charismatic movement as some make out. 90% of Pentecostals and Charismatic folk are Bible-believing, Jesus loving, godly people who seek to live holy lives and to love others. Just because many of them actually enjoy church and have fun there and sing with all their hearts, laugh, shout, dance in their worship, doesn't mean that they are out-of-control wacky wackies. They are not like the cold religious folk who may yell like Commanche Indians at the football match on Saturday and sit like wooden Indians in church on Sunday.If by church you mean "The Church" as in the body of Christ, yes, I agree it was not the Body that hurt me but rather this one ministry.
If by church you mean the ministry that I was a part of, no, it was that church specifically as I took my objection to participating in the deliverance course and event all the way to the actual leaders of the ministry and they required that I participate in it, so it was that church, if one could call it that, that did directly spiritually hurt and abuse me.