Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
My first inclination is to say no, but without rereading all of your posts I will refrain from answering.antinomianism by definition is advocating sin. It means against law. So, yes/no question: do you think I am teaching against the law of God?
Then why do you seem to assume that I do? Let me quote what you said, in response to me saying to DL that the idea of sinless perfection for a believer in Jesus is a ludicrous idea:My first inclination is to say no, but without rereading all of your posts I will refrain from answering.
If you beleive you can live without sinning, my answer will be "NO" you don't advocate sin.
If a man sins. big time or small time, the penalty is the same...second death.Then why do you seem to assume that I do? Let me quote what you said, in response to me saying to DL that the idea of sinless perfection for a believer in Jesus is a ludicrous idea:
"It isn't a ludicrous idea if you read 1 John 3:9.
Just as fig seeds cannot bring forth grapes, neither can God's seed bring forth liars, thieves, adulterers, or murderers."
Firstly:
When I say that Christians are "sinners," what you read into it is that they are liars, thieves, adulterers, and murderers. Yet I made it clear previously that I was talking about spiritual immaturity and the inclination to commit sins not leading to death (1 John 5:14-16).
Would you prefer I say...Took a pencil from work, or, Cut someone off on the freeway ?But you keep on using this kind of exaggerative language without any restraint.
I am not bearing anything against anyone !This is why I told you before that you are bearing false witness against your neighbor.
Are you not saying just that ?If you claim that by my saying that sinless perfection is a ludicrous idea, that I am saying true believers can be liars, thieves, adulterers, or murderers and continue therein (as you have also exaggerated previously), then there is something wrong in your responses.
Perhaps you can state which position you are on, before we proceed aby further.It's called "cognitive dissonance" because you are contradicting yourself. One time you claim I am talking about liars, thieves, adulterers, or murderers being believers, and another time you claim I'm not advocating sin. This is an obvious contradiction.
I will depend on God's word being true, specifically 1 Cor 10:13..."There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man: but God is faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it."Unless, of course, you are now claiming that I'm not a believer. Most certainly I do not believe that anyone, including yourself, is sinless. Perhaps in this moment you could claim that you're not sinning. But given certain circumstances, adversities, confrontations, hostilities, situations, or whatever you call it, when the stress of it is coming on you like a ton of bricks, I have serious doubts about your claims. And even if you claim you are sinless in this moment, I have serious doubts about your claim.
The word "continuing", and some use "practicing", both refute the meaning of the verse.Secondly:
Your citing 1 John 3:9 is taken out of context and misrepresented. That verse means "continue sinning" (if you examine the Greek tense), which means true believers can commit sin, but they then repent. It's not about being in a sinless condition, but it's rather about the direction of one's life. But of course, you don't believe this, because you can't abandon your pet doctrine, because you're too proud (or deceived) to think you could be wrong.
What does "We turn out of our sins" mean, please? "Stop sinning, perhaps? Thanks.We turn of our sins because we are born again, not to get born again.
Do you mean that Christians are sinless in this life?Yes, we do stop sinning. Doesn't eman we are incapable of sinning
No, this is not true. Firstly, I am NOT a "sinless" advocate. Nevertheless, it appears to me that you aren't taking into account the sanctifying work of the Holy Spirit. The Spirit of God dwelling in the heart casts out the evil one, per the answer to the Lord's Prayer. 1 Jn. 1:9 "If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us of our sins, and to CLEANS US FROM ALL UNRIGHTEOUSNESS."There is almost a guarantee that we actually "sin even more" after salvation.
No, he wasn't talking about his present condition, but his past. 1 Cor. 15:9 - because he persecuted the church. So he is referring to his condition before his conversion. Most certainly Rom. 8:13 is a description of how he was living, since he never taught anyone to do what he himself wasn't already doing himself, or at least willing to do - 1 Cor. 9:27 (he practiced what he preached)Paul said we are no better than any sinner because "all" are under sin. Romans 3:9
Paul himself claimed that he was, using the present tense "I am" the chief of sinners after salvation, 1 Tim. 1:15
Jesus came to destroy the work of the devil - 1 Jn. 3:8. Therefore, He accomplishes the driving out of the evil one - 1 Jn. 5:18.HOW is it then we can actually become worse?
Let's get the enemy in the picture and then it becomes obvious as to HOW. We engage the Word, the scriptures. AND so does our enemy, our adversary, the devil:
Mark 4:15
And these are they by the way side, where the word is sown; but when they have heard, Satan cometh immediately, and taketh away the word that was sown in their hearts.
Temptations, lusts of various sorts, evil thoughts, <---ALL of these things come from within. Who else is within to cause this issue? Temptations, lusts and evil thoughts are not materially dangling outside of us. These are internal matters and they are of and from OUR ADVERSARY
Get the adversary in the picture and deal with the fact. Those who do so will instantly see the utter foolishness of claiming any forms of sinlessness and will also instantly turn to the Grace and Mercy of our Lord, knowing what/WHO we look forward to being delivered FROM
This notion that none of us have to engage temptations, lusts, evil thoughts internally and it does not cause defiling are simply not listening to JESUS. These are people who have been turned into claimers of the Word, yet DENIERS of that same Word, always seeking to justify the entirety of themselves when the fact is that will not and can not happen until our ADVERSARY is totally taken away out of our PICTURE and that has not yet happened to anyone in this present life:
Mark 7:
21 For from within, out of the heart of men, proceed evil thoughts, adulteries, fornications, murders,
22 Thefts, covetousness, wickedness, deceit, lasciviousness, an evil eye, blasphemy, pride, foolishness:
23 All these evil things come from within, and defile the man.
Can it be any clearer?
"from within, out of the heart-proceed evil thoughts-these evil things come from within, and defile"
This is not optional ^^^
IF you are claiming we don't come under "more attacks" because of our insights into this subject I'd simply refer you to Paul's own claim in 2 Cor. 12:7, that just to remind him of the fact a "messenger of Satan" was put upon his flesh.No, this is not true. Firstly, I am NOT a "sinless" advocate. Nevertheless, it appears to me that you aren't taking into account the sanctifying work of the Holy Spirit.
The Spirit of God dwelling in the heart casts out the evil one, per the answer to the Lord's Prayer. 1 Jn. 1:9 "If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us of our sins, and to CLEANS US FROM ALL UNRIGHTEOUSNESS."
Therefore, the notion that we sin even more after salvation is nonsense.
Our conscience is awakened, and we become more aware of sin we commit, but the idea includes repentance. A saved person has a continual attitude of repentance from sin, because they treasure the peace of God in their heart.
No, he wasn't talking about his present condition, but his past. 1 Cor. 15:9 - because he persecuted the church. So he is referring to his condition before his conversion.
Most certainly Rom. 8:13 is a description of how he was living, since he never taught anyone to do what he himself wasn't already doing himself, or at least willing to do - 1 Cor. 9:27 (he practiced what he preached)
Jesus came to destroy the work of the devil - 1 Jn. 3:8. Therefore, He accomplishes the driving out of the evil one - 1 Jn. 5:18.
Deu. 30:6 - we who belong to Christ are circumcised of heart. Gal. 5:24
Didn't say that, but certainly STRIVE to be sinless. When we are sanctified, we are commanded to have our minds renewed (Romans 12:2).Do you mean that Christians are sinless in this life?
You're reading into this passage something it doesn't say. "Thorn in the flesh" is a figure of speech meaning something happening that irritates him. It's NOT sin. The "messenger of Satan" is SOMEONE who attacks him with slanders and tries to destroy his godly work. This is implied in several of his epistles. Messengers of Satan will be thrown into the lake of fire - Mat. 25:41, Rev. 12:9.IF you are claiming we don't come under "more attacks" because of our insights into this subject I'd simply refer you to Paul's own claim in 2 Cor. 12:7, that just to remind him of the fact a "messenger of Satan" was put upon his flesh.
No, read :13 - it was a trial TO THE GALATIANS, because of a SICKNESS in Paul's body at the time. You should not misrepresent scripture.Paul also said temptation was in his flesh, Gal. 4:14
The messenger of Satan was not sin coming from his own heart. It was an affliction coming from outside of him. Of course he was honest, since he boasted of his own weakness (to control his situation), so that the power of Christ would be revealed. His tolerance of the adversity was coming from the endurance that God provides, and not from his own willpower, this is how Christ is glorified.And no matter how hard he prayed, it didn't go away.
I'm actually quite happy Paul was honest about it.
The word of reconciliation is evangelistic in nature. Again, you take scripture out of context. 2 Cor. 5:19 means that God was in Christ during His ministry on Earth, reconciling the unregenerate world to Himself. Eph. 2:5 "while we were dead in trespasses and sins, God rich in mercy raised us up to life and seated us with Christ in the heavenlies" - means that God did not count our trespasses against us, but loved us beyond it, and freely gave us the gift of the Holy Spirit. Note the description - "Holy." This holiness is accounted to us at first when we are spiritual infants, and then the Holy Spirit sanctifies us, which takes away the power of sin. It's called spiritually maturing. It's not an allowance of practicing sin, which Paul makes clear in 1 Cor. 6:9-10. It is necessary for us not only to believe that Christ's work atones for our sins, but also we are to repent from our sins, trusting that God will help us do so - 1 Jn. 2:1.The principle involved here is this: We don't count sins against people, 2 Cor. 5:19
"The devil made me do it" is a poor excuse for lack of a repentant attitude.But we DO, CAN and SHOULD by all means count them against the devils.
If you want to blame someone, blame Adam. But that doesn't accomplish the necessary dealing with our present condition. Since God will judge everyone according to their deeds (yes, even Christians), we must appeal to the power of the Spirit to overcome sinful habits - Rom. 8:13, Gal. 5:16, etc.It's not a one sided story
Again, you misrepresent Paul in this matter. Paul repented of his sins. He no longer persecuted the church. His epistles make it clear he was not committing sins leading to death. One does not have to wallow in the slime of the worst sins in order to identify with sinners. Jesus identified with us, and yet was without sin. He knew no sin, so says scripture. Peter wrote for us to walk in His steps. John wrote that we must walk in the same manner as He walked.I provided the scripture for it. You're welcome to enjoy it: 1 Tim. 1:15 wherein Paul describes himself as the present tense, "I am" the chief of sinners. Not used to be or was, but "I am."
"Satan prowls about..." doesn't mean you aren't responsible for your sins. It doesn't mean you should just give in. No, every Christian is in a spiritual war, and we must trust the power of God and do whatever it takes (Eph. 6:10-18) to overcome - 1 John 2:15-17, 5:2-5.And I'd suggest it was not just Paul in that picture, but the tempter also. That's the only reasonable way this can be seen.
You basically have a typical account that is void of the "other parties" to these matters, the devil and his messengers.
Why do you write them out of the picture when scriptures do not is the real question.
I disagree. Paul was referring to his past condition. Rom. 7 is not about serving sin in present actions, but about the deliverance that is in Christ (Rom. 8:2). The Spirit of God living in the born-again Christian sets one free from sinful habits, and clears our conscience (Heb. 9:14).Oh no that wasn't the case at all. Paul clearly defined that he both did, not used to do evil, in Romans 7:19, but that he also had evil present with him, Romans 7:21 and that his flesh still served "the law of sin," in Romans 7:25, exactly none of which were "past tense" presentations.
Are you admitting that the devil has control over you, and that you can't tell the truth of this matter? I'm beginning to believe you about that (i.e. concerning you). My advice to you is that you abandon your sinful idea and start asking the Lord to cleanse your heart. You need to do a lot more study in scripture to begin discerning where you are going wrong.There is no therefore. We still have an active enemy who tempts, deceives, and destroys. Particularly destroying the ability to tell the truth of this matter
Are you talking about being honest about the true condition of your soul? That certainly is a first step to repentance and faith.The instant any recognize that temptations transpire in 'mind' and that places the tempter "in mind" to do so, they stop pulling their own leg on the subject
Oh, I'm fairly 1000% certain that it's exactly as stated, a "messenger of Satan"You're reading into this passage something it doesn't say. "Thorn in the flesh"
You'll have to excuse me but I can't help but laugh at that explanation, trying to blame some other guy.The "messenger of Satan" is SOMEONE who attacks him with slanders and tries to destroy his godly work. This is implied in several of his epistles. Messengers of Satan will be thrown into the lake of fire - Mat. 25:41, Rev. 12:9.
Well, I'm glad you actually got that far. And, P.S. it's not some other guy. It's the tempter, the devil, our adversaryNo, every Christian is in a spiritual war
The devil tempts in mind. Who are we trying to kid that it's "control?"Are you admitting that the devil has control over you
Since you persist in misrepresenting scripture, I'm done with you.Oh, I'm fairly 1000% certain that it's exactly as stated, a "messenger of Satan"
You'd have to erase that to convince me it doesn't say what it clearly says
You'll have to excuse me but I can't help but laugh at that explanation, trying to blame some other guy.
Paul flat out says that sin dwells in his flesh in Romans 7:17-21, concluding that evil "is present" with him and that his flesh serves the law of sin, vs. 25. This ain't the problem of some other guy and if you think people are devils then we have other theological issues
So you might consider starting with a very basic fact that we do have an adversary, a tempter that tempts us internally. Paul even stated he had "temptation" in his flesh, Gal. 4:14
So the evidence on this matter is super abundant.
Some other guy? grinning
Well, I'm glad you actually got that far. And, P.S. it's not some other guy. It's the tempter, the devil, our adversary
The devil tempts in mind. Who are we trying to kid that it's "control?"
I can keep it in check, but it is in mind, beyond any doubt, that Satan tempts us all in mind. I also believe Satan steals Word from my heart, just as Jesus said happens in Mark 4:15. That's why we only see in part and as through a glass, darkly.
Do you deny this happens? Let me hear you deny ever being tempted in mind by THE TEMPTER. Let's start there.
Well, you know full well that only means I don't see things like you.Since you persist in misrepresenting scripture, I'm done with you.
For a Christian, the devil does not reside within us. There can be demons that plant thoughts and images into our mind, but it is coming from the outside, because the Holy Spirit dwells in us. The Holy Spirit casts out the evil one, as 1 John 5:18 declares. Therefore, for Christians, our worst enemy is ourselves. There is still a propensity to be tempted in everything we once did as habit and practice. But Jesus is a healer. We can indeed be transformed by the renewing of our minds. I'm not so arrogant as to claim I'm sinless or have no issues. But as my faith has grown, most temptations I used to fall by are miniscule. Sure, I keep finding new ones that I have to battle and overcome by the power of the Spirit. We can overcome by faith, as John declared in 1 John 5:4.Well, you know full well that only means I don't see things like you.
Our difference is I can read and comprehend what someone else sees and delineate differences without getting frustrated. But my patience is limited as well.
If someone can't see we have an invisible enemy that we battle internally the conversations can never get far, and I think it's because of the adversary who doesn't care to have light shed on them
Oh? So Satan stands in front of us, floats at our shoulder, whispering audibly?For a Christian, the devil does not reside within us.
No offense, but I'm seriously doubting this going by most of your posts.Our difference is I can read and comprehend
This is a prime example of you not being able to comprehend the Bible as a whole.