First thing, you are a very good and a very honourable person for serving in the military for so long. That you did 11 years, being in both the Marines and the Army, fighting for your country and for your people. It's something to be proud of and you are a very good person for doing that. I don't know how many other people appreciate soldiers for what they do for us today, but I value them VERY greatly and it's been a fantastic thing that you have been doing it and for so long
I think that mentality and way of thinking which you have would be ok. I don't see why not. I think the term "pacifist" has been taken over and exaggerated by the hippies. Do I think the Anabaptists think of wars in the same way that hippies think of war/violence/self defence? NO
I think you would be ok
I once again congratulate you for serving your country
Hello. Thank you for your post, but I'd like to clarify the Anabaptist view regarding pacifism. I think we are often mischaracterized (or disregarded quickly as quacks) before we're ever given a chance to explain what we believe, or why we believe it. So if you'll please grant me the opportunity to explain, I'd humbly appreciate it.
The Anabaptist belief regarding nonviolence stems completely from Jesus' teachings (Contrary to popular belief... it wasn't from the "hippies". Although, I'm sure that many of them would love to believe that they are the catalyst for a pacifist movement). So then why do we believe what we believe? There are several verses in the Bible that point us in this direction. So I'll do my best to explain.
First, (and really, I needn't go beyond this, but I will) Jesus tells us that He brings us a new commandment... to love our enemies as we love ourselves. But why? What has changed? Well, clearly several things change after his death, but that is a different discussion, so I will keep to the topic. So how then do we love our enemies? Well, Jesus tells us exactly how, and it's not easy. He tells us to turn the other cheek... but more importantly, he tells us right after that, "Do not resist an evil person." That is a HUGE statement to make and it is crystal clear. But somehow, that part of it usually gets left out of the story. He also tells us, "If he asks for your shirt, give him your coat also." I think a lot of Christians look at this and think, "Well... maybe in a perfect world." But Jesus certainly didn't live in a perfect world. What if He actually meant what He said? And where is our faith if we disregard it? Can we truly believe?
Second, when Pilate asks Jesus why He doesn't just release himself and take his throne (if he is king), Jesus replies, "This kingdom is not of this world. If it was, my disciples would fight for me." It was never Jesus' intention that we should hold power over others in order to defend Him (Matthew 20:25-28). In fact, Jesus tells us to do the exact opposite. We are called to be servants, not hold positions of power over people. People often say, "Then why did Jesus tell his disciples to buy swords?" The answer to this question is in the context of what is written in the Gospels. When they did buy swords, why were two swords enough? What did they do right after they bought the swords? Jesus knew he had to be arrested, and the swords were part of the plan to get arrested. And even if you don't believe that... then you at least have to believe that Jesus never intended his disciples to actually use the swords, because He tells Peter, "Don't even allow this... For those who live by the sword will die by the sword" when Peter tried to cut the guard's ear off trying to defend Jesus.
Third, Paul tells us that our battles are not physical, but spiritual instead. Why does he go through so much trouble to redefine what a Christian warrior looks like? He alters every aspect of what a warrior for Christ looks like and fundamentally is. And what is now our weapon, if not the Bible? Notice that the sword has been replaced.
Four, when Jesus' disciples wanted to burn the Samaritans alive for snubbing Jesus, what was Jesus' response to them? He rebuked them by saying, "You do not know what spirit you are of... for the Son of Man did not come to destroy the lives of men, but to save them."
Five, Jesus tells us not to fear what can be done to our body, but fear what can be done to our soul instead. Everything Jesus tells us to do requires faith and humility. It requires sacrifice and strength. Pacifism is NOT weakness. If anything, it takes more guts and strength of character to do what Jesus asks of us than anything else in this world. It goes against our human nature. And why does He ask it of us? The answer is simple... because we are to represent Him and what He did for in this world. It is one of the many ways we witness to the world. It is one of the many ways that we show our faith to Him. It's one of the many ways we sacrifice and put others first. It's one of the many ways we love Jesus and others.
If we truly desire to be Christian and to follow Christ, then we cannot simply put His teachings on a shelf somewhere and say, "Yeah, that would be nice in a perfect world... BUT..." We must be proactive and at least believe in and try to follow His commandments. Otherwise... who are we really following, and where is our faith? Blessed are the Peacemakers, for they shall inherit the Kingdom of God.