It seems to me the more I'm reading these posts and thinking about it, the majority of our problems with the threads boils down to two things:
1) Too many threads all debating the same topic
2) Any discussion about homosexuality instantly turns into debate
I agree with the sentiment that you don't want to be 'segregated', but I'm starting to think that subforums might be the answer. However!
I didn't see this suggestion.
What about a subforum for the sole purpose of debating homosexuality and Christianity? That way those of us who don't want to get into yet another go-round argument don't have to, and debating won't be allowed on the topic elsewhere?
And maybe there should be a Homosexuality forum in the Christians-only area? A place where a homosexual Christian or someone seeking advice on the topic can go without it deteriorating into yet another argument? (if it's enforced that debating is not allowed in there; take it to the debate subforum)
I realize my advice probably weighs about as much as a feather, given how briefly I've been here, but that seems to be the two biggest problems: Any time Christians want to discuss homosexuality among themselves, even if they themselves are Christians, they cannot without it turning into an argument with the other camp.
Just my two cents, for whatever it's worth.