- Aug 19, 2018
- 16,266
- 11,037
- 71
- Country
- Australia
- Faith
- Atheist
- Marital Status
- Married
All decisions we make are determined by existing and prior influences. There has been an effectively infinite chain of events which has resulted in me sitting here writing this sentence. They have all led to this point. From the major events - I was born at a specific time and place, to the minor ones - it's raining today, to the seemingly inconsequential - I broke a string on my guitar last night.
There is no way that existence cannot be described other than determined.
The question is then not whether we make decisions that affect the trajectory of future events - I obviously decided to do this rather than something else. But if free will is defined as the ability to make decisions that are not determined by prior events and we could rerun the last hour exactly as it happened and make a different decision, then something actually needs to be different. But rerunning it exactly as it happened means that nothing is different.
So free will cannot be compatible with determinism. And if existence is deterministic then free will is an illusion.
There is no way that existence cannot be described other than determined.
The question is then not whether we make decisions that affect the trajectory of future events - I obviously decided to do this rather than something else. But if free will is defined as the ability to make decisions that are not determined by prior events and we could rerun the last hour exactly as it happened and make a different decision, then something actually needs to be different. But rerunning it exactly as it happened means that nothing is different.
So free will cannot be compatible with determinism. And if existence is deterministic then free will is an illusion.