• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • Christian Forums is looking to bring on new moderators to the CF Staff Team! If you have been an active member of CF for at least three months with 200 posts during that time, you're eligible to apply! This is a great way to give back to CF and keep the forums running smoothly! If you're interested, you can submit your application here!

The Downfall of Christian "Rock"

eutychus

the phlegmatic one
Feb 7, 2004
615
60
40
Louisville
Visit site
✟23,562.00
Faith
Calvinist
Politics
US-Others
So the other day I came to this conclusion (and this isn't for the "Christian rock" listener to take lightly):

Christian Rock has been confused with Loud Christian Music. In order for something to have the legitimate label "rock," not only does it have to be some type of mood-inducer, but it has to be talented. The Christian subculture has confused "talent" for "anything that sounds loud." This can range from Kutless (who has the potential to be loud) to the hardcore bands like Extol. If you think about it, there's not much of a median where there is true instrumental ingenuity and prowess, because there is no need for it in the land of Christian "Rock."

On the other hand, bands that are really talented are considered contemporary, mainly because they know how to handle an acoustic. Either that, or they're completely dismissed by the Christian market. Thankfully, I'm fine with the latter since I don't agree with GMA or CCM, but still...it's a downfall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jayadeva444

MewithoutYou

HxC 4 Life
Mar 6, 2004
123
6
40
North Carolina
✟283.00
Faith
Christian
umm not try to rag on but i not really understanding what you talking bout

For one thing Extol is Metal not hardcore, and they are very talented just cuz they play loud doesn't mean that they don't play there instruments very well.

And just a message to those who consantly call hard music Hardcore
the hardcore genere died in the early 90's with bands like minor threat and black flag

Everything you listen to today is some version of Metalcore

Which i believe is part of the downfall of christian hard rock, the market is overflowing with so many generic metalcore bands that is redicoulus. I know there are still so great bands in the midst of the junk but it seems retarded to have 2000+ bands (if you don't believe me just check out purevolume or hxcmp3.com) that all sound the same "screaming with breakdowns"

It's time for a new genere to take over and this time let's try keep it clean
 
Upvote 0

MewithoutYou

HxC 4 Life
Mar 6, 2004
123
6
40
North Carolina
✟283.00
Faith
Christian
umm not try to rag on but i not really understanding what you talking bout

For one thing Extol is Metal not hardcore, and they are very talented just cuz they play loud doesn't mean that they don't play there instruments very well.

And just a message to those who consantly call hard music Hardcore
the hardcore genere died in the early 90's with bands like minor threat and black flag

Everything you listen to today is some version of Metalcore

Which i believe is part of the downfall of christian hard rock, the market is overflowing with so many generic metalcore bands that is ridiculous. I know there are still so great bands in the midst of the junk but it seems retarded to have 2000+ bands (if you don't believe me just check out purevolume or hxcmp3.com) that all sound the same "screaming with breakdowns"

It's time for a new genere to take over and this time let's try keep it clean
 
Upvote 0

AndOne

Deliver me oh Lord, from evil men
Apr 20, 2002
7,477
462
Florida
✟28,628.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Calvinist
Marital Status
Married
I disagree with the origonal poster - although there has been a trend leaning towards the music getting louder and harder recently - which IMO is long overdue. I remember the days when the only hard Christian rock consisted of Ressurrection Band and Petra. They were the pioneers of Christian hard rock - but horrendous musically. Despite the trend there are still plenty of good contemporary christian artists out there - you just aren't listening to the right radio/internet stations...
 
Upvote 0

Qyöt27

AMV Editor At Large
Apr 2, 2004
7,879
573
39
St. Petersburg, Florida
✟89,359.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
I mean, for my preference in Industrial music, there are few well-known (and even then, not very well-known) Christian bands that perform it. But I'd say that if someone is performing Industrial or any of its varients (Industrial Metal, Industrial Dance/EBM, Goth-Industrial, etc.) that they'd have to be pretty talented, considering the layering and technics that go behind it.

Likewise, I'm sick of hearing Industrial or Electronic Rock bands (yes, there is a difference) labelled as 'Cyber Punk'. About the only band that could come close to being an Industrial-Punk band is Lard, and that's only because Jello Biafra was the lead singer, backed by the guys from Ministry (which is mainly what it sounded like). And is there any difference between Metalcore and Punk-Metal, like what's described on www.allmusic.com?

MewithoutYou said:
Which i believe is part of the downfall of christian hard rock, the market is overflowing with so many generic metalcore bands that is ridiculous. I know there are still so great bands in the midst of the junk but it seems retarded to have 2000+ bands (if you don't believe me just check out purevolume or hxcmp3.com) that all sound the same "screaming with breakdowns"
If you ask me, I think that's also the downfall of secular hard rock, too.

MewithoutYou said:
It's time for a new genere to take over and this time let's try keep it clean
I wholeheartedly agree, for both the Christian and secular music scene's sake. Luckily, there's already a push in the secular market towards Neo Post-punk, so maybe the Christian scene will lean that way too (that'd be kinda interesting). Personally, though, I'm holding out for the next big Industrial wave. C'mon, everybody, we know it's bound to happen sooner or later (although I bet most people would prefer later ;) )
 
Upvote 0

swingnscream

more music - dance our troubles away
Jan 25, 2004
3,119
189
I roll with the foxes and hunt with the hounds
✟19,202.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
I'm gonna agree with eutychus on this one. "Rock" is so general these days. If ppl don't know what to call it [especially in the Christian scene] they call it "Rock music", as if they we trying to appease everybody with going with a general genre. I personally wish ppl would be a lil more specific and know the difference between: punk rock, hard rock, acoustic rock, light rock, and Rawk -as in modern rock music. Oh! Let alone, I hope there becomes a much better understand of the seperation of hardcore & metal music from the "rock" scene. Examples:

Stereo Motion -rock [w/ touch of classic rock 'n' roll]
RelientK -poppy punk rock
Kutless -hard rock
Haste the Day -hardcore

Yeah I know things get mixed together when the hard mainstream bands go lighter, and the still growing young bands try to go harder ...it gets a blurry line, but still... Not everything is simple "rock" or "hardcore" or "punk". I haven't heard any good new "punk" so I've got no idea what's up with the big hype about punk these days? I guess it's those hard rocker kids.. hah! They make me laugh. Anyhow...
So yeah.. let's start describing genres more accurately. That'd be sweet.


....Done ranting now. :holy:
 
Upvote 0

Qyöt27

AMV Editor At Large
Apr 2, 2004
7,879
573
39
St. Petersburg, Florida
✟89,359.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
swingnscream said:
Yeah I know things get mixed together when the hard mainstream bands go lighter, and the still growing young bands try to go harder ...it gets a blurry line, but still... Not everything is simple "rock" or "hardcore" or "punk". I haven't heard any good new "punk" so I've got no idea what's up with the big hype about punk these days? I guess it's those hard rocker kids.. hah! They make me laugh. Anyhow...
So yeah.. let's start describing genres more accurately. That'd be sweet.
Which one would you like me to start with? ;)
 
Upvote 0

Qyöt27

AMV Editor At Large
Apr 2, 2004
7,879
573
39
St. Petersburg, Florida
✟89,359.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
swingnscream said:
Haha. Nice. :cool: Start at home.. whatever's home scene for you. That's what I'd suggest.
Ookay...I will (too bad there's no 'mischevious' smiley here...that'd really fit right about now). That means the Industrial/Goth scene...

Industrial - Used as a catch-all simultaneously for heavy synth-rock and the Industrial music sub-section of rock, Industrial specifically refers to the brand of experimental electronic music originally performed by the English band Throbbing Gristle starting around 1975. The music is composed of several electronic sampling techniques, including tape music, musiqué concreté (don't ask me what either of those are; I haven't a clue), and everyday noise constructed into something abrasive, dissonant, and filled with the same rage that fueled British Punk rock, but instead of directed outwards at society, the rage was turned inward at oneself. Industrial's main theme early on, and strongly continuing today (with few exceptions), is dehumanization.

Around 1987, German band KMFDM fused rock guitars into the mix, helping to create a more digestable though no less abrasive form of Industrial rock which other bands would use as influence in creating Industrial Metal. Ever since around 1989, the term is also used to describe the General Hard Rock-Industrial fusion that hit the pop charts starting in the early 90s with Nine Inch Nails. Currently the only Christian band I know of (by hearing them) that performs this strain of Industrial is Mortal, who sound somewhat like a cross between NIN and Skinny Puppy, and hit the CCM/Christian Metal charts around 1991 with the singles 'Enfleshed (The Word Is Alive)' and 'Mytho-X'.

Industrial Dance - Throbbing Gristle's brand of abrasive music eventually softened and after the band broke up and it's members went their seperate ways, other bands that were influenced by TG and frontman Genesis P'Orridge (also well-known as one of the creators of Acid House techno music) infused more dance beats and a more structured orchestration into the music. Sometimes this type of music is lumped under the label 'Darkwave', but is actually a legitimate progression of Industrial. It was originally known as Electronic Body Music, or EBM (the accepted term now is actually Industrial Dance).

Generally, while the music is not exactly as sonically dissonant, it is just (if not more so) abrasive and disturbing. Skinny Puppy, Front 242, Nitzer Ebb, and possibly even more or less recent bands like VNV Nation (which also has large Goth-Industrial influences) fall under this category. As said before, it is more dance-oriented, and is often the type of music heard in the background or in a lot of underground clubs in some darker movies. Often, I believe the term Electro-Industrial refers to music very similar to Industrial Dance, but the music is generally much harder and the dissonance is much higher than typical Industrial Dance music.

Industrial Metal - Practically the first Industrial Metal band was Ministry [along with Ministry side projects RevCo (that's an abbreviation of the full name), and the Industrial/Hardcore Punk fusion group Lard, which featured former Dead Kennedys frontman Jello Biafra and several members of both Ministry and RevCo. Lard basically sounds like Industrial Metal performed with the speed and somewhat similarity to the sound of a classic Hardcore Punk band (and lyrically reflected RevCo's sense of humor and Biafra's lighter political views)], who was very guitar focused and applied heavy layers of distortion to the music and vocals all the while playing at a speed similar to the thrash or speed metal of bands like Anthrax and early Metallica. The lyrics deal with much of the same themes as plain old Industrial and Industrial Dance, but most of the Industrial Metal bands that have showed up on the mainstream since the mid-90s have taken the more humanized and more standard-structure lyrics that Nine Inch Nails (which is also sometimes referred to as Industrial Metal) introduced to the genre and actually just come off sounding like harder versions of NIN (not that that's a bad thing, though; several of them are very talented).

Sometimes the synths and classic Industrial part of the music can be very prevalent, and sometimes not so much, dominated more by the guitar work and very little on the backing synths. Bands as varied as Stabbing Westward, Rammstein, Orgy, Deadsy, Gravity Kills, Filter, and notably Marilyn Manson fall into this genre. Christian bands (that I've heard) that fall into this style are Circle of Dust (who released their first album in 1994, and their last in 1998, and even covered Steve Taylor's song 'Am I In Sync?' for a tribute album), which later broke up and two bands formed from its ashes: Klank, where most of the members went and who takes a very Metal-oriented route; and Celldweller, composed of only (AFAIK, multi-instrumentalist) Klay Scott, who takes a much more dancey road, but maintains the strong guitars that would make this classified as Industrial Metal. Currently, Celldweller's song 'Switchback' can be heard in the background for the theatrical trailer for Catwoman, and it was briefly featured in a short burst in one of the Spider-man 2 trailers.

Industrial Metal, in particular, came under fire from religious organizations and parent's groups in the aftermath of Columbine since the two guys listened a lot to the style. Around this time the popular-but-very-false KMFDM acronym 'Kill ---- Depeche Mode' started being quoted a lot (the accepted meaning of the acronym is 'Kein Mitleid für Die Mehrheit', which translates to 'No Mercy (or Pity) for the Majority'). I would say that Columbine was the last nail in the coffin for the mainstream Industrial wave that started around 1994, with the release of NIN's controversial song and video for 'Closer' and continued for about two years afterward fueled by the copycat NIN bands and featured on all the Mortal Kombat soundtracks. Since 1999, the few Industrial bands that have come onto the mainstream or continued to be popular (such as NIN) have been very few and far between and not played very often. I don't know if this decline really had anything to do directly with Columbine, but the artists that got targeted were Industrial or Industrial Metal bands, and probably were more or less targeted because of the shock tactics they employed, and not so much the lyrical content (except for Manson, of course).

Post-punk - In the late 70s, as the original wave of British Punk was dying down, former members of punk bands, punk bands themselves, and new bands influenced by the DIY ethic of punk started producing more artsy and challenging music, sometimes using synthesizers very frequently. This large, varied group of artists is collectively classified as Post-punk, and includes everything from early Goth Rock such as Bauhaus, Joy Division, and Siouxsie and the Banshees; New Wave, such as A Flock of Seagulls, Adam Ant, and Gary Numan; New Romantic (which is often synonymous with New Wave), such as Spandau Ballet, Duran Duran, Soft Cell, and early Depeche Mode; the guitar-based rock of the Comsat Angels and the Replacements; and later, Post-Hardcore like Fugazi and possibly Hüsker Dü (I swear I saw them listed as a post-hardcore band somewhere). So-called 'Minnesota Rock', which was heavily influenced by Hüsker Dü, might even be considered a part of this, and included The Replacements and early Soul Asylum.

Post-punk was practically a dead genre by 1985 or 1986, since it had splintered so many times and those subgenres had each earned distinctive places within general rock music, so the Post-punk label eventually dissolved, except when listing a band that actually was once considered it. Right now, the secular music scene is going through a Neo Post-punk faze, since the influence of pop-punk on the airwaves and increased popularity in older alternative bands like The Cure (which is actually a Goth Rock band) have lead to a batch of new artists picked up from indie labels (or remaining there but given mainstream support) that have a lot of Post-punk influence mixed in with the new Garage rock and ethereal music of the White Stripes and Radiohead, along with the new New York Punk of The Strokes. Bands like Franz Ferdinand, Modest Mouse, Electric Six, Hot Hot Heat, Interpol, Snow Patrol, and the new leanings of Blink 182 (like Post-punk, where punk bands started expanding their sounds, it seems pop-punk bands now are doing the same) are properly called Neo Post-punk.

Goth Rock - A style that grew out of Post-punk, Goth Rock originated as a deeply introspective, ethereal type of music that grew increasingly morbid as years went by. The three bands commonly referred to as the original Goth band are Sex Gang Children (who were chronologically first), Bauhaus, or Joy Division (the last two of which were probably commercially first). Bauhaus is often credited as defining the sound, for some odd reason, and their lyrics definitely do have that 'Frankenstein'-esque classic horror feel to them [Bauhaus would later split, with lead singer Peter Murphy starting a solo career of his own which was more along the lines of Peter Gabriel or Kate Bush-type adult contemporary pop, and two bands which consisted of the remaining members-first Tones On Tail, which was actually just guitarist Daniel Ash and drummer Kevin Haskins pairing up with Bauhaus roadie Glen Campling, who played bass (the group would have a hit with the single 'Go!' a few years after it was initially released); later, Ash, Haskins, and former Bauhaus bassist/vocalist David J would form the band Love And Rockets, who had at least two hit singles in the US: 'So Alive' and 'No New Tale To Tell']. Joy Division's lead singer would end up commiting suicide, and the remaining members regrouped to become the über-influential Alternative Dance band New Order.

Musically, Goth Rock is very ethereal-sounding, making good uses of haunting synthesizers and plodding or likewise-haunting guitar chords. The style became very popular in England during the 80s, and several bands, such as the Sisters Of Mercy (who were very much also a dance-rock band), the Mission UK, Gene Loves Jezebel, All About Eve (ex-Gene Loves Jezebel bassist Julianne Regan's band, which performs a sort of pop-Goth adult contemporary strain; who also have some truly great songs like 'Tuesday's Child', 'December', and 'Strangeway'), and The Cure (who started hitting US charts a lot when they had 'happier' songs). As far as the mainstream charts were concerned, Goth Rock's popularity died out in the early 90s, both a large amount of influence went into some Industrial music, forming a new genre.

Goth-Industrial - The ethereal synths and/or vocals of Goth Rock put over the pounding beats of Industrial rock and Industrial dance, Goth-Industrial really gained steam in the early 90s, with bands such as VNV Nation, and continued on into the late 90s with rock and adult contemporary flavored artists such Vast and Switchblade Symphony. Usually, Goth-Industrial isn't as hard as Industrial or Industrial Dance, but is generally harder than typical Goth Rock.

The varieties of style within this isn't quite as large as Industrial; the two extremes are pretty much covered by five of Vast's songs-'Touched', 'Free', 'Pretty When You Cry', 'I Don't Have Anything', and 'My TV And You'-and the Switchblade Symphony song 'Clown' or 'Rain', all of which (from both artists) are varied from one song to the next, at times (in Switchblade Symphony's case) using savage Industrial drums and synths on 'Clown' to the far more placid 'Rain', or the various flavors of adrenaline flowing through Vast's music contrasted against tender love songs (which actually tends to be a focal point of Goth-Industrial songs: lost love or romantic longing). This is probably the purest strain of Goth Rock left on the American side (a lot of it actually originates in America, actually), and probably the most listenable Industrial to most casual mainstream ears, despite the popularity of harder Industrial bands on the Top 40.

Edit: Actually, the 'Fear' that I was talking about apparently was performed by Sarah McLachlan, my mistake. Although, that song does have a very Goth-Industrial feel to it.

Goth Metal - This style generally started up in the early to mid 80s, and basically combined Los Angeles metal and hardcore with the dreaminess of Goth Rock. Lately, this form of 'Goth' has been what the mainstream in America is focusing on, with Evanescence (admittedly, they aren't as hard as nearly every other Goth Metal band, but they are Goth Metal nonetheless) and Lacuna Coil, who originated in Italy (also, Evanescence and Lacuna Coil don't have as much influence in the hardcore and Los Angeles metal sections as other bands do; in fact, it's hardly there at all, and what they do have is mostly derived from grunge or the Alternative Metal that existed before nu-metal came around or Alt. Metal got a bunch of Industrial influences).

Many Goth Metal bands do, in fact, come from Scandinavian countries [Sweden and Finland in particular]. Nightwish or Evergrey, for example. However, a lot of the early Goth Metal bands were from around the Los Angeles area's 'death rock' (not death metal, though) scene centered around Christian Death (whose name is supposedly inspired by a goof on the name of fashion designer Christian Dior, but for some reason makes their statements against organized religion a focal point of their music). Cradle of Filth and Christian Death are readily recognized as Goth Metal, but are way too extreme and focused on thrash and death metal/black metal to garner mainstream attention aside from the occasional single or video. Type O Negative is a little more speed metal influenced (although I think they lessened it down to just standard metal), and is tongue-in-cheek most of the time (they even did a cover of a Neil Young song). I don't listen to very much Goth Metal, and the extent of it is contained to the pop acts or pseudo-pop acts, like Evanescence, Lacuna Coil, Nightwish, and the occasional Evergrey and Type O Negative (to date, I only have about two or three songs from either of them). I don't like black metal or death metal so I don't even take a step toward it, and thus I effectively cut out a lot of Goth Metal.

(Continued in next post)
 
Upvote 0

Qyöt27

AMV Editor At Large
Apr 2, 2004
7,879
573
39
St. Petersburg, Florida
✟89,359.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
(Continued from last post)

And finally... (this may seem a little weird)

Visual Kei - This is actually a subgenre of Japanese rock, which is heavily influenced by Goth Rock, Thrash Metal, and Industrial Metal combined with experimentation that could be classical in origin, but often employs playing around with time signatures. Of course, fashionwise, the style is equally influenced by Ziggy Stardust-faze David Bowie and the traditionally-Japanese Kabuki theatre. Drawing from so many styles means the music itself is somewhat chaotic, but often times is excellent musically. It does, by any means, provide something 'different' to listen to. Notable bands that perform this are X Japan (who did record one entirely English song, entitled 'Drain'; that particular song also has a very Industrial vibe to it), Malice Mizer, Gackt (Malice Mizer's lead singer), and Dir en Grey.

Many of these bands and artists use English much the same way most Japanese do, in a form called Engrish, which is thrown haphazardly (and very randomly) throughout Japanese lyrics or on street signs, buildings, food packaging, even hygiene products. A lot of the songs also tend to have English titles, even if the English contained in the song makes absolutely no sense.


Industrial and Gothic music (this statement, of course, excludes the visual kei bands) often employs religious symbolism or imagery in its lyrics, but usually in a non-offensive form (not like Marilyn Manson's, Christian Death's, or Cradle Of Filth's highly religiously offensive material) that requires individual interpretation. Many of the artists do know Scriptures well, since many of them do make references to particular verses. However, hardly any of these bands could be labelled as Christian bands (in the sense of CCM or praise music, which these certainly aren't; there are probably many Christians in Industrial and Goth bands, but it's not a readily known fact that there are very many; I'd take a shot in saying they mostly would come from a religious or Christian background, but are probably agnostic in belief). Despite that fact, the subject of spirituality is appealed to quite often, usually in a soul searching type of way. Mainly it appeals to the human side of spirituality (meaning, the search for God or the feeling we as humans get from being spiritual). Like I said before, though, it's largely metaphoric, so it's always up to individual interpretation. That's just what I get from it usually.


Darn character limit on posts. How is 16390+ letters too long, huh?

I think that about covers the Industrial/Goth section. Umm-hmm. Next?
 
Upvote 0

eutychus

the phlegmatic one
Feb 7, 2004
615
60
40
Louisville
Visit site
✟23,562.00
Faith
Calvinist
Politics
US-Others
MewithoutYou said:
Everything you listen to today is some version of Metalcore

Which i believe is part of the downfall of christian hard rock, the market is overflowing with so many generic metalcore bands that is redicoulus. I know there are still so great bands in the midst of the junk but it seems retarded to have 2000+ bands (if you don't believe me just check out purevolume or hxcmp3.com) that all sound the same "screaming with breakdowns"

It's time for a new genere to take over and this time let's try keep it clean

Very good call.
 
Upvote 0

bleechers

Christ Our Passover!
Apr 8, 2004
967
74
Alabama
Visit site
✟1,509.00
Faith
Christian
The decline in quality in both secular and CCM can be attributed to (at least) some of the following:

1. Label control - Fewer and fewer bands are "home-grown"; starting off locally building a base and growing artistically. This weeding out process helps produce the "intangibles" that make a good band "good". Today, most bands are created by labels because they fit the current mold (and are consequently discarded when the mold changes). This has always been a part of popular music, but in 2004 it is as true as it has ever been since the early 60s. This is why most bands come and go, there is no real sustaining talent there, just the production of forgettable music that fits the current mold.

(Anybody remember the Backstreet Boys being touted as being the "new Beatles"? Were they insane? Quality lasts. Heck, a recent release of Dean Martin's recordings from the 50s hit number 25 on the pop charts... the guy's been dead for over a decade! And the Beatles "One" LP featuring some songs that had been released 15 times before was the fasting selling LP in history surpassing "Black and Blue" by the Back Street Boys... but the labels never learn and never think long-term.)

2. Trends - the program "American Idol" reveals this truth: the winner will be one who can do vocal athletics having nothing to do with the song. In secular pop music Whitney Houston and Michael Bolton started the trend of doing vocal trick just 'cause you can. No style. No heart. No originality. No artistic growth. In CCM the trend is to (a) mimic the world (and a copy is never as good as the original) and (b) produce formulaic music (Praise and Worship, etc.).

3. Chorus-based music - writing songs built around the pattern of repetetive choruses and including the same worn-out gimmicks (the acapella bit, the acoustic picking bit, etc.).

4. Same Studio - As labels seek to control the "scene" they employ the same studio engineers and producers thus leading to similarly produced CDs with similar-sounding music. This is even worse for singers who use studio musicians... this just compounds the problem.

5. Loud Live - sorry to say it, but volume and distortion covereth a multitude of lousy musicians. It is killing "craft" and originality.
 
Upvote 0

DJ B.K.

But I'm Le Tired...
Jun 24, 2003
9,948
139
40
Cincinnati, Ohio
Visit site
✟33,551.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Constitution
bleechers said:
The decline in quality in both secular and CCM can be attributed to (at least) some of the following:

1. Label control - Fewer and fewer bands are "home-grown"; starting off locally building a base and growing artistically. This weeding out process helps produce the "intangibles" that make a good band "good". Today, most bands are created by labels because they fit the current mold (and are consequently discarded when the mold changes). This has always been a part of popular music, but in 2004 it is as true as it has ever been since the early 60s. This is why most bands come and go, there is no real sustaining talent there, just the production of forgettable music that fits the current mold.

(Anybody remember the Backstreet Boys being touted as being the "new Beatles"? Were they insane? Quality lasts. Heck, a recent release of Dean Martin's recordings from the 50s hit number 25 on the pop charts... the guy's been dead for over a decade! And the Beatles "One" LP featuring some songs that had been released 15 times before was the fasting selling LP in history surpassing "Black and Blue" by the Back Street Boys... but the labels never learn and never think long-term.)

2. Trends - the program "American Idol" reveals this truth: the winner will be one who can do vocal athletics having nothing to do with the song. In secular pop music Whitney Houston and Michael Bolton started the trend of doing vocal trick just 'cause you can. No style. No heart. No originality. No artistic growth. In CCM the trend is to (a) mimic the world (and a copy is never as good as the original) and (b) produce formulaic music (Praise and Worship, etc.).

3. Chorus-based music - writing songs built around the pattern of repetetive choruses and including the same worn-out gimmicks (the acapella bit, the acoustic picking bit, etc.).

4. Same Studio - As labels seek to control the "scene" they employ the same studio engineers and producers thus leading to similarly produced CDs with similar-sounding music. This is even worse for singers who use studio musicians... this just compounds the problem.

5. Loud Live - sorry to say it, but volume and distortion covereth a multitude of lousy musicians. It is killing "craft" and originality.
Excellent post. Couldn't agree more.
 
Upvote 0