• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • Christian Forums is looking to bring on new moderators to the CF Staff Team! If you have been an active member of CF for at least three months with 200 posts during that time, you're eligible to apply! This is a great way to give back to CF and keep the forums running smoothly! If you're interested, you can submit your application here!

Converting from Catholic to Protestant

Status
Not open for further replies.
I was never a hard-practicing Catholic, but I have gone through all the sacraments up to and including Confirmation. I go to a Catholic college and still am not a practicing Catholic. Up until recently I doubted a lot of things that I have faith in now and this brings me to a question in my faith. After reading a lot of stuff I've found that with a Protestant congregation I feel like I might be able to get closer to God. I don't feel the need to go through priests in order to form a relationship with Jesus but that's how I feel being a Catholic.

What does converting from Catholic to Protestant entail? Does it require anything other than converting in my own mind? I understand that I'm a Christian either way and the basic faith is the same. I just feel restricted as a Catholic whereas I might be able to work on my relationship with Jesus a lot more as a Protestant.

Thanks for your help guys.
 

BBAS 64

Contributor
Site Supporter
Aug 21, 2003
10,004
1,778
60
New England
✟598,432.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
finchuck said:
I was never a hard-practicing Catholic, but I have gone through all the sacraments up to and including Confirmation. I go to a Catholic college and still am not a practicing Catholic. Up until recently I doubted a lot of things that I have faith in now and this brings me to a question in my faith. After reading a lot of stuff I've found that with a Protestant congregation I feel like I might be able to get closer to God. I don't feel the need to go through priests in order to form a relationship with Jesus but that's how I feel being a Catholic.

What does converting from Catholic to Protestant entail? Does it require anything other than converting in my own mind? I understand that I'm a Christian either way and the basic faith is the same. I just feel restricted as a Catholic whereas I might be able to work on my relationship with Jesus a lot more as a Protestant.

Thanks for your help guys.
Welcome Finchuck,

I can to some extent understand where you are coming from. Your relationship with God is your relationship. I do not think the church of Rome says you have to go though a priest to have that, sometimes it feels like that is what they "local churches" are teaching. It seems either local churches do not understand all of what Rome teaches or that Rome suffers an inabilty to clearly and logicly explain their own techinging in an understandable way to it's clergy and memebers.IMHO

What does converting from Catholic to Protestant entail?
I do not know of any set of rules that apply to this conversion. My conversion was solely based upon the Scripture and the agreement with God of my own fallen condition, the clear teaching that Jesus paid it all, I am now his and he is now mine, and that he loves me for me not because of what I do and fail to do. Matter of the mind for me to some extent yes, but more a matter of the heart.

Work on your relationship with him to your best abilty with all that you have, all that you are. I found that ever since my conversion I am closer to God than I ever was before.

For His Glory Alone! :clap:


BBAS
 
Upvote 0

JillLars

It's a Boy! Jace David- Due 1/20/07
Jan 20, 2003
3,105
115
42
New Hope, MN
Visit site
✟3,944.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Single
I was raised catholic and went through all the sacraments up to confirmation, and I go to a Lutheran church now. I don't consider it "converting" because I am simply switching denominations, I was a Christian while I was Catholic, and I'm a Christian now that I'm Lutheran, in fact, I prefer to be identified as a Christian, rather than by a specific denomination.
 
Upvote 0

Fiat

Let It Be Done
Sep 5, 2003
216
7
Visit site
✟397.00
Faith
Catholic
Why do you feel restricted as a Catholic? I'm confused. And why do you feel it necessary to "feel the need to go through priests in order to form a relationship with Jesus but that's how I feel being a Catholic." ? A relationship with Jesus is between you and Jesus. Are you referring to confession/penance in this statement?
 
Upvote 0

Bruce S

Well-Known Member
Dec 28, 2002
936
27
75
✟1,232.00
Faith
Protestant
Metanoia02 said:
While I can't go into the details on this forum, if you want to clearly understand what you are giving up, I invite you to come to the OBOB forum to make sure you understand what you are considering. Either way, may God be with you!
Argh. Why did you post this here? This man came HERE to talk to US, not have Catholics come and tell him to get back INTO the RCC faith! This is exactly what we Protestants have been asking in this forum. Leave US alone to deal with OUR issues. You have your own forum, if this man wanted the opinions of Catholics, he would have posted there.

K?
 
Upvote 0

JillLars

It's a Boy! Jace David- Due 1/20/07
Jan 20, 2003
3,105
115
42
New Hope, MN
Visit site
✟3,944.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Single
Relax bruce, metanoia was simply extending an invitation, he/she may feel restricted by the catholic faith because he/she may not fully understand it. I have come to know loads more about the Catholic faith from members on this board, does that mean I'm going to leave the Lutheran church I go to? nope, it doesn't change my decision, but I have been very happy to have the oppurtunity to talk with the Catholics on this board, it isn't about winning people, its about informing people, and met didn't do anything wrong by inviting this member to visit the OBOB boards. So, take a chill pill! :)
 
Upvote 0

Bruce S

Well-Known Member
Dec 28, 2002
936
27
75
✟1,232.00
Faith
Protestant
OK ...

Here is my conversion story.

I was raised a Roman Catholic. Went to RCC gradeschool, Mass every Sunday, choir. At one point, in my adolescence, I even wanted to be a priest. Hard to believe that now.

As a young adult, I got consumed with the desire for money, power, fame, fortune. Worked excessively, compulsively, I thought that I HAD to achieve, ,to provide, to BE SOMEONE, something, make a niche for myself. It was terrible actually, the powerdriving.

I had no faith, put God on the back burner, never even gave Him a thought.

I found myself drinking a little at nights to calm my nerves, and help me sleep. At first, it was a good thing, worked well, allowed me to perform better, but over time, that turned out to be a curse. I became alcoholic, slowly, over the years I started to lose what I wanted. It resulted in a divorce, shame, degredation, terrible things, terrible times.

I went for help, rehab, and in AA they stress the need for a relationship with God. I wanted that, sought it, prayed a LITTLE, went to church, Catholic and Protestant for a time, NOTHING, absolutely nothing happened. My relationship did not "kick in" I asked why, why, others "got IT" I didn't. So I settled in without God and tried to continue in my quest for restoration of all I had lost.

Fast foreward, ten years of sobriety.

I got behind in paying taxes, had a new business, new wife, son, and life had some promise again. BUT the inability to find the means to pay those back taxes weighed on me, consumed me, I COULD NOT see a way out of the mess of those debts. So, despite that decade of AA, I got frustrated when some people there hurt me, deeply, and walked on that. Of course, what always happens when one does that happened to me. Drinking became an option again, and I succumbed.

This two years of drinking took me where no man should go. I got arrested for an act of terrible judgement while drunk, something that I didn't even KNOW was a crime, but KNEW was "wrong". I was on TV, my family was shamed, it was the final nail in my coffin. Destruction loomed. Then to top this story off, I got sued for an internet post, told the truth about a flim flam company, they hated that, sued me personally, ,AND corporately.

I have spent over 100k in legal bills, and had to file for bankruptcy. I was forced back into ANOTHER rehab, and rejoined AA, embarrassement was total. Here I was "Mr. AA" the guy that started meetings, sponsored many, talked and walked the line, and I'm back, as a rank beginner again. You have no idea how that crushed my ego.

I came back to the second and third steps of AA.

2. "Came to believe that a power greater than ourselves, could restore us to sanity."

3. "Made a DECISION to turn our will, and our lives, over to the care of God as I understood him."

Now I had tried this before, for years. But I knew I had to conform, to do this. So I went back to church again.

The RCC faith was not the answer, I looked at it again, but the Legalisms, the emphasis on ritual, the dullness, the works issues, fear and scaring that I saw as an emphasis there, the Mary worship, this all was something that I didn't want. It turned me off totally, I knew, deep in my heart, that if I were to try this again, I would fail. I couldn't fail again, I was NOT going to get another shot at this again, I needed to get God, not think about getting God.

I went to several Protestant church's, for a few months, I tried, honestly to "get IT" and like before, nothing worked, it was gratifying, they were good people, they were kind, but the spirit of God wasn't entering into my soul
and life.

Finally, somehow, the Lord said to me "try this other place". I had no idea why, I didn't even know the name of the church, or the denomination.

Standing at the door, looking in, watching all those people carrying Bibles INTO the service seemed odd. Why bring a Bible, when they provided them in the pews? And a BAND!? What is up with that, and the hand waving, the emotionalism, I was NOT comfortable with any of that, the service was exhuberant, lively, people were INVOLVED.

Wow. I had never seen such a thing. I wanted to come back the next week, my wife didn't. "THOSE PEOPLE" made her uncomfortable, the service was too much for her. BUT she knew that I was devestated, ,and the quest for God would benefit her too, I was looking, needing, and she, being the loving woman she is, allowed for us to go back the next week.

This church has about 1/2 hour of contemporary Christian music, and a choir of 50 people...next week, on the second song, OPEN THE EYES OF MY HEART LORD, I broke..started sobbing, I was totally embarrassed. Convicted of my sins. I could NOT stop crying. This is NOT ME, I'm NOT that sort of man. Because I was in an environment of prayer, conviction, and the Holy Spirit, IT finally happened.

What I've come to learn and see, is that for ME, in MY circumstances, the intellectualising of faith was the stumbling block, and the Catholic baggage, of continual sin, ritual, Mass, confession, statues, Rosary, etc was the thing that kept me from accepting and understanding that FAITH is NOT doing things, jumping up and down, sign of the cross, candles, priests, Popes, rules, rules, and MORE rules.

Faith is in your heart. Simple is for me. Reading the Bible for myself, not having some bureacracy telling me that I HAD to do what the Bible said wasn't necessary, getting a PERSONAL, one on one, relationship, direct to God, ,without the middlemen.

My family was upset. Naturally. They thought I was a nut, had joined a cult [Assembly of God] and they were hoping that I would "see the light" and come back to the one true faith, as they thought of Catholic faith.

I never will. I clearly see, for ME now, that I need the entire faith of the Bible, and the oddities of Pentacostalism are not so odd now. Raising hands in prayer, emotional services, singing from the heart, talking in tounges, the entire Pentacostal experience has added so immensely to my soul, my spirit, my walk with God.

I found Jesus, when I tossed out that mismash of accumulated mediavial baggage of Catholicism, the barriers to a direct walk, and without the priest, Pope, and ritual, came to "get" what I always sought.

Now are there good Catholics out there, ,that have "it" YES, absolutely, I have many friends who are good Christians, I engage them almost daily on religous matters, watch EWTN nightly, love some of the men there who teach. There is MUCH to admire in the RCC, much to learn. BUT for me, I can't do THAT again, that kept me out of communion with God. As I continue to study and learn, I have a newer and deeper understanding of the Reformation, what it was, why they did it, and why Protestants are different.

Don't be sucked back in. Take a good look, jump in, the water really is deep here, and the swim with God is a nice one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LightHearted
Upvote 0

OpenMinded-Protestant

Pray for our Military!!
Oct 15, 2003
62
3
44
Oklahoma
✟198.00
Faith
Christian
Hi, from my experiences... (my fiance "converted" from catholicism) as far as the religion differences i think that you'll find theres just a few less rules... I think your biggest transitions will be with your Family (that is if they too are Catholic) whenever a family member becomes a Protestant, "aka Protester of Catholicism" the family ussually takes this as a huge slap in the face, and an embarrasment.. just be ready for the backlash!! hope this helps!
 
Upvote 0

Fiat

Let It Be Done
Sep 5, 2003
216
7
Visit site
✟397.00
Faith
Catholic
JillLars said:
Relax bruce, metanoia was simply extending an invitation, he/she may feel restricted by the catholic faith because he/she may not fully understand it. I have come to know loads more about the Catholic faith from members on this board, does that mean I'm going to leave the Lutheran church I go to? nope, it doesn't change my decision, but I have been very happy to have the oppurtunity to talk with the Catholics on this board, it isn't about winning people, its about informing people, and met didn't do anything wrong by inviting this member to visit the OBOB boards. :)
Exactly, well said Jill and God bless you.
 
Upvote 0

BBAS 64

Contributor
Site Supporter
Aug 21, 2003
10,004
1,778
60
New England
✟598,432.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
OpenMinded-Protestant said:
Hi, from my experiences... (my fiance "converted" from catholicism) as far as the religion differences i think that you'll find theres just a few less rules... I think your biggest transitions will be with your Family (that is if they too are Catholic) whenever a family member becomes a Protestant, "aka Protester of Catholicism" the family ussually takes this as a huge slap in the face, and an embarrasment.. just be ready for the backlash!! hope this helps!
OMP

Good Point I got some of that early in my walk with the Lord. That can be the worst part, after a while they will start to ask good useful questions at least in my case. Being from the N.E of USA I am seeing more and more questions as it relates to the Faith and God's nature.


For His Glory Alone! :clap:

BBAS
 
Upvote 0

Bruce S

Well-Known Member
Dec 28, 2002
936
27
75
✟1,232.00
Faith
Protestant
One other thing, that popped into my mind after writing my testimony.

I noticed that so many of the folks at my church seemed to be Ex-Catholics. I asked my pastor, "you know most of the members here [1,000+], there seem to be many, like me, that used to be Catholic. How many do you think there are like me?" He answered...and I almost fell down "Bruce, I think about 60% of our membership, are like you, from that background."

Man, that confirmed it for me, I was not alone, many, like me, found God only by leaving the RCC.
 
Upvote 0

ukok

Freaked out, insecure, neurotic and Emotional
Mar 1, 2003
8,610
406
England
Visit site
✟27,206.00
Faith
Catholic
Bruce S said:
One other thing, that popped into my mind after writing my testimony.

I noticed that so many of the folks at my church seemed to be Ex-Catholics.

Humour me Bruce, i can't imagine how you would possibly have known that the majority of a congregation numbering more than 1000 in total, were 'formerly' Catholic ? Did they perhaps have some secret handshake, wear a sticky label "Whooppee...I'm a convert from Catholicism! :clap: " ? How exactly did you know this before you even mentioned it to your pastor?

How many do you think there are like me?" He answered...and I almost fell down "Bruce, I think about 60% of our membership, are like you, from that background."
Wow, what a win for your pastor...:sigh:

Man, that confirmed it for me, I was not alone, many, like me, found God only by leaving the RCC.
How exactly do you know that many of them were a. like you. b. only found God after leaving the RCC ?

I would have thought that if a person had not already 'found God' they would hardly be inclined to join yet another Church. Surely a percentage of those people already 'knew' God, or had a serious desire to know God more deeply, but failed to endeavour to do so while in the RCC?

And just so you know, i think that I am allowed to formulate and post an opinion here as i haven't converted to Catholicism, yet.:) so i'm looking at this as i see it, and i can't see how you presume to know so much about so many people, unless of course you have had very indepth conversations with the entirity of your church congregation ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: nyj
Upvote 0
A

ABDIarise

Guest
finchuck said:
I was never a hard-practicing Catholic, but I have gone through all the sacraments up to and including Confirmation. I go to a Catholic college and still am not a practicing Catholic. Up until recently I doubted a lot of things that I have faith in now and this brings me to a question in my faith. After reading a lot of stuff I've found that with a Protestant congregation I feel like I might be able to get closer to God. I don't feel the need to go through priests in order to form a relationship with Jesus but that's how I feel being a Catholic.

What does converting from Catholic to Protestant entail? Does it require anything other than converting in my own mind? I understand that I'm a Christian either way and the basic faith is the same. I just feel restricted as a Catholic whereas I might be able to work on my relationship with Jesus a lot more as a Protestant.

Thanks for your help guys.

It really isn't about being a catholic or a protestant, it is about being a Christian where you are free in Christ Jesus and not under such bondages. There is a perfect law of liberty that exist in Christ that surpases all the man made religions and such. There is freedom in Christ, but not to make it a stumbling block to other brothers. Jesus is your high priest and you can come to the thrown boldy now through Jesus. No one can get in between that unless you let them.

Blessing to you on your journey and may the God of peace sanctify you wholly :)
 
Upvote 0

Plan 9

Absolutely Elsewhere
Jul 7, 2002
9,028
686
72
Deck Six, Cargo Bay Two; apply to Annabel Lee to l
Visit site
✟27,857.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Private
ukok said:
Humour me Bruce, i can't imagine how you would possibly have known that the majority of a congregation numbering more than 1000 in total, were 'formerly' Catholic ? Did they perhaps have some secret handshake, wear a sticky label "Whooppee...I'm a convert from Catholicism! :clap: " ? How exactly did you know this before you even mentioned it to your pastor?


Wow, what a win for your pastor...:sigh:


How exactly do you know that many of them were a. like you. b. only found God after leaving the RCC ?

I would have thought that if a person had not already 'found God' they would hardly be inclined to join yet another Church. Surely a percentage of those people already 'knew' God, or had a serious desire to know God more deeply, but failed to endeavour to do so while in the RCC?

And just so you know, i think that I am allowed to formulate and post an opinion here as i haven't converted to Catholicism, yet.:) so i'm looking at this as i see it, and i can't see how you presume to know so much about so many people, unless of course you have had very indepth conversations with the entirity of your church congregation ?

When I read some threads in the PRE forum, I feel an immediate urge to convert to Catholicism. Why do you think that is, ukoc? ;)
 
Upvote 0

Lanakila

Not responsible for the changes here.
Jun 12, 2002
8,454
222
60
Nestled in the Gorgeous Montana Mountains
Visit site
✟32,973.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Working on that Plan 9. I mentioned earlier today P/R/E people are about a whole lot more than being not Catholic. I know I am. I rarely even talk about Catholicism anywhere but here. Definetly not at church.
 
Upvote 0

Plan 9

Absolutely Elsewhere
Jul 7, 2002
9,028
686
72
Deck Six, Cargo Bay Two; apply to Annabel Lee to l
Visit site
✟27,857.00
Faith
Methodist
Marital Status
Private
Lanakila said:
Working on that Plan 9. I mentioned earlier today P/R/E people are about a whole lot more than being not Catholic. I know I am. I rarely even talk about Catholicism anywhere but here. Definetly not at church.
It rarely comes up in my life, either. I see Catholics as brothers and sisters in the faith with some doctrinal differences, and that's all. :confused:
When I come here I feel like I'm trapped in some nightmare episode of Family Feud.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benedicta00
Upvote 0

Lotar

Swift Eagle Justice
Feb 27, 2003
8,163
445
44
Southern California
✟27,144.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
finchuck said:
I was never a hard-practicing Catholic, but I have gone through all the sacraments up to and including Confirmation. I go to a Catholic college and still am not a practicing Catholic. Up until recently I doubted a lot of things that I have faith in now and this brings me to a question in my faith. After reading a lot of stuff I've found that with a Protestant congregation I feel like I might be able to get closer to God. I don't feel the need to go through priests in order to form a relationship with Jesus but that's how I feel being a Catholic.

What does converting from Catholic to Protestant entail? Does it require anything other than converting in my own mind? I understand that I'm a Christian either way and the basic faith is the same. I just feel restricted as a Catholic whereas I might be able to work on my relationship with Jesus a lot more as a Protestant.

Thanks for your help guys.
:wave: Welcome to the forums :wave:

Converting doesn't usually entail much. Which congregation are you considering? Most will just have you go through a basics class, where you will learn about what the church believes, but that's pretty much it. I pray you find a deeper relationship at this new church. :)



A word to our Catholic brethren. Please remember the rules, and how we don't bother people with similair situations on the OBOB :prayer:
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.