Obviously you only had a superficial knowledge of the conference and its content. Just got home from the closing Mass concelebrated by Archbishop Carlson and scores of other priests, accompanied by traditional, contemporary, Latin, and gospel hymns, including a prayer of the faithful response in four languages, sung by 1500 enthusiastic voices.
Archbishop Carlson gave an affirming, encouraging homily filled with personal stories and insights.
My other activities of the day--an amazing post Vatican II wrapup by Sr. Honora Werner. She compared the past fifty years to a concerto--the first movement full of enthusiasm and energy--the second movement, reflective and somber--the third movement, even more energetic than the first.
She spoke of the need for "theologically sound" hymns after Vatican II (and, as I've said, one thing I like about contemporary hymns is that the lyrics are often taken directly from the Bible--and the readings of the day) and, although she still likes chant and traditional hymns, she isn't unhappy to see the four-chord hymns with trite lyrics go (how many times have I said that here?)
Another quote: "We have eyelids but we don't have earlids."
She said Pope Francis calls musicians 'subversive creatures' in church. How often do people leave Church quoting the homily? How often will they leave humming or singing something they have heard or sung?
She talked about keeping our ears to the people and integrating ministry with our lives, sustained by prayer.
She quoted St. Augustine: "Be sure your life sings the same tune as your mouth."
My traveling companion and I have decided to get the DVD of her talk...
I then went on the organ crawl to an organ concert at Christ Cathedral, came back to an industry showcase by OCP and a huge sample pack, followed that by a blissful workshop with a 'small' publisher--a charming Irish couple reminding me of my heritage, followed by a musical technology workshop, and, finally the closing Mass.
Two more sessions tomorrow. What a blessing to spend this blissful week in the city of my heart, where I raised my three children, and to do something I love.
Yes, it was on my dime--communications is my vocation, and music is my avocation at the moment--and it was worth every penny.