PDA

View Full Version : Mishna - Sanhedrin 5:5


debi b
20th September 2004, 07:39 AM
To convict someone of a crime punishable by death, a panel of 23 judges is empowered. There must be a majority vote by at least two.

If 12 vote for aquittal and 11 vote for conviction, he is acquitted.

If 12 vote for conviction and 11 vote for aquittal, or

11 vote conviction and 11 vote aquittal and one abstains, they add to the judges two at a time - up to 71.

Does anyone know if latter writings have anything to add on this issue?

debi b
20th September 2004, 03:58 PM
Has anyone anything to add...I am curious about latter writings commenting on this issue.

Rabbi Klein
21st September 2004, 01:27 AM
Dear Debi,

What do you mean by latter writings?

R. Klein

debi b
21st September 2004, 10:06 AM
Talmudic writings. I do have Mishna and Tosefta on the shelf, but not Talmud.