PDA

View Full Version : Jewish Renewal


simchat_torah
23rd June 2004, 06:50 PM
There seems to be a "neo-Chassidic" movement taking place today within Judaism. A movement that focuses on evangelism, creativity and the arts, worship, etc. I mentioned it in another thread, so I thought I'd start something seperate as it was way off base (a rabbi trail... hehe, ok ok ok, a rabbit trail).

Many of the Jewish Renewal services have contemporary music with guitars, drums, cellos, violins, congas, etc. They incorporate art and worship in a modern form while maintaining the traditional practices. You can find lots of stuff on the web, but here's a couple of blurbs you might find interesting:

What is Jewish Renewal?

Jewish Renewal is a new movement within Judaism. It is a kind of neo-Hasidism, in that it seeks the spiritual renewal of Judaism, but "neo" because it insists on full equality for women and a creative return to the process of transforming Hallakhah (Jewish law) so that it continues to be a living path to connection to God. The philosophy of Jewish Renewal is articulated best in the theological writings of Abraham Joshua Heschel (see particularly The Propehts and God In Search of Man and Man Is Not Alone) and Zalman Schachter Shalomi (Paradigm Shift), Arthur Waskow (Down To Earth Judaism, GodWrestling) and Michael Lerner (Jewish Renewal: A Path to Healing and Transformation).

Judaism is a distinctive blending of spirituality and a liberatory political vision. But when Judaism abandoned its liberatory message, the Judaism that survived was unable to command the respect and adherence of many Jews. Those who sought spiritual vitality often found themselves attracted to other traditions. Others became disillusioned with all forms of spirituality, assuming that it would necessarily be associated with patriarchal and repressive social realities.

So Jewish Renewal seeks a revolutionary transformation of the world: away from the ethos of selfishness and materialism and toward an ethos of love and caring. Its political vision is spelled out in two books by Rabbi Michael Lerner: The Politics of Meaning and Spirit Matters: Global Healing and the Wisdom of the Soul. One of its central ideas is that we need a new definition of productivity, efficiency and rationality. Institutions and social practices should be judged efficient or productive not only to the extent that they maximize wealth and power, but also to the extent that they maximize our capacities to be loving and caring, ethically/spiritually/ecologically sensitive, and capable of transcending a narrow utilitarian attitude toward other human beings and toward the universe so that we can respond to them with awe, wonder and radical amazement at the grandeur of Creation.

Jewish Renewal is an attempt to take God seriously at every level of our being. That requires more than adding a few phrases about social justice to an existing liturgy or ritual. It is an attempt to make us more fully alive to God's presence the world, to build a life that is God-centered, and to provide us with a way of reclaiming the unique spirituality of Judaism, deeply embedded in political consciousness but not only political.

Jewish Renewal energy is flowing through all the various denominations of Jewish life - and it will eventually help to transform all of them.

There's even an organization which has become the coordinator of some Jewish Renewal activities. It is called Aleph (http://www.aleph.org/) and you can go their website to get a list of Jewish Renewal synagogues or to find other valuable Jewish Renewal activities.

And there are many people in the Reform, Conservative, Reconstructionist and Orthodox movements of Judaism who are actually embodying aspects of Jewish Renewal and making it happen in their respective movements. So it would be a mistake to think that any one organization is "the" Jewish Renewal movement. Rather, you will find elements of Jewish Renewal consciousness in a wide variety of institutions and movements in Jewish life today, and it our intention at TIKKUN to support and nurture that consciousness.

So, at the present moment the promise of Jewish Renewal is only a promisory note to be filled in by you. A set of ideas have been developed, and there are some inspired teachers and spiritually alive communities. But the full vision is yet to be instantiated in the world.

TIKKUN magazine is committed to supporting the development of a Jewish Renewal movement wherever it occurs. Our writers are Orthodox, Reconstructionist, Conservative, Reform - not to mention the many writers who are not part of any particular religious movement or those who are adamantly secular. In TIKKUN you'll find our attempts to clarify and deepen a Jewish Renewal consciousness, but you'll also find that many of our articles are not written from that perspective. We provide a place for secular Jews as well as for those seeking Jewish Renewal.

But if you are interested in Jewish Renewal, we want to encourage you to become part of the TIKKUN community, because it is in TIKKUN that we try to provide the space for both the theological and the political discussions that provide the foundation for a spiritual renewal of the Jewish people. And we encourage you also to participate in the activities of Aleph, and many other kinds of Jewish Renewal programs described in TIKKUN.


- www.tikkun.org/renewal (http://www.tikkun.org/renewal)



What is Jewish Renewal?

Jewish Renewal is dedicated to revealing Judaism's inner spirit and nurturing the spiritual life of Jews. It makes use of both traditional practices such as meditation, chanting and music and traditional Kabbalistic and Hassidic sources, to enhance both individual and communal practice. Jewish renewal seeks to transform and renew the kavanah (spiritual intention) with which Jews of all kinds practice Judaism. It seeks to bring creativity, relevance, joy and an all-embracing awareness to spiritual practice, as a path to healing our hearts and finding balance and wholeness.

Jewish renewal is a "movement" in the sense of a wave in motion, a grassroots effort to discover the modern meaning of Judaism as a spiritual practice. It sees itself as transdenominational, a tendency that transcends the boundaries of the various movements. Jewish renewal draws heavily on the thought of Reb Zalman Schachter-Shalomi (http://www.neveikodesh.org/rebzalman.html), which is a loving critique of the limitations of traditional Rabbinic Judaism and a call to continue the ongoing renewal of Jewish life in our time, as the Talmudic rabbis did in theirs. Jewish renewal is sometimes referred to as "Neo-Hasidic" or "Four Worlds (http://www.neveikodesh.org/FourWorlds.html)" Judaism (a reference to the "four worlds (http://www.neveikodesh.org/FourWorlds.html)" of Jewish mysticism). While it seeks to restore the spiritual vitality characteristic of the Hasidic movement of pre-war Europe, Jewish renewal believes, along with the Reconstructionists, that Judaism is an evolving religious civilization.

Jewish renewal acts to fully include all Jews and to respect all peoples. Jewish renewal helps to heal the world by promoting justice, freedom, responsibility, caring for all life and the earth that sustains all life —tikkun olam

Jewish renewal has long been committed to a fully egalitarian approach to Jewish life and welcomes the public and creative input of those who were traditionally excluded from the process of forming the Jewish tradition.


- http://www.neveikodesh.org/Home/JewishRenewal.html


You can also find information at these sites:
http://www.jewishrenewal.org (http://www.jewishrenewal.org/)
http://www.aleph.org/
http://www.jewishrenewallifecenter.org/



shalom,
yafet

Shamash Of Yeshua
24th June 2004, 01:31 AM
Shalom and Shalom,

Mat 23:1-3 HNV
Then Yeshua spoke to the multitudes and to his talmidim, (2) saying, "The scribes and the Perushim sat on Moshe' seat. (3) All things therefore whatever they tell you to observe, observe and do, but don't do their works; for they say, and don't do.

Rom 3:1-4 HNV
Then what advantage does the Jew have? Or what is the profit of circumcision? (2) Much in every way! Because first of all, they were entrusted with the oracles of God. (3) For what if some were without faith? Will their lack of faith nullify the faithfulness of God? (4) May it never be! Yes, let God be found true, but every man a liar. As it is written, "That you might be justified in your words, and might prevail when you come into judgment."

Zec 8:18-23 HNV
The word of the LORD of Armies came to me. (19) Thus says the LORD of Armies: "The fasts of the fourth fifth, seventh, and tenth months shall be for the house of Yehudah joy and gladness, and cheerful feasts. Therefore love truth and shalom." (20) Thus says the LORD of Armies: "Many peoples, and the inhabitants of many cities will yet come; (21) and the inhabitants of one shall go to another, saying, 'Let us go speedily to entreat the favor of the LORD, and to seek the LORD of Armies. I will go also.' (22) Yes, many peoples and strong nations will come to seek the LORD of Armies in Yerushalayim, and to entreat the favor of the LORD." (23) Thus says the LORD of Armies: "In those days, ten men will take hold, out of all the languages of the nations, they will take hold of the skirt of him who is a Jew, saying, 'We will go with you, for we have heard that God is with you.'"

May HaShem bring the World into HIS Ways which HE gave through Moshe and Promised to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and HE will fulfill in the Messianic Age.

Shalom and Shalom,

Tag

Sephania
24th June 2004, 08:59 AM
ST, what of this? creativity and the arts

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 09:42 AM
Often you will find artists bringing in artwork that is judaically centered. You'll also see various "interpretive" dances, etc.

that kinda stuff...

iitb
24th June 2004, 10:28 AM
I looked at the website for the Jewish Renewal Center in Boulder, and it seemed pretty Liberal. Of course, that could be because it's in Boulder. ;)

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 10:40 AM
I've seen Renewal Centers range anywhere from Chassidic to Reconstructionist (oy!) so just be sure to look into what it is before you head out. It actually started as a Neo-Chassidic movement, so there are a lot of more Orthodox Renewal Centers out there. The movement, however, is open to all sects of Judaism.

muffler dragon
24th June 2004, 11:14 AM
Could this in any way, shape or form be construed as an 'ecumenical' type of effort for Judaism?

I have my reservations about such in christianity, and I wasn't sure if this might follow along the same path.

Nathan

Talmidah
24th June 2004, 11:42 AM
My children attend a Chabad summer day camp and we sometimes go to their services & classes during the week after I pick them up. I have been to a couple of services that seem along the lines of Yafet is talking about. I didn't realize that there was a name for it though...I just figured that this Chabad was a little different than the others we've been to :)

Henaynei
24th June 2004, 12:17 PM
in reviewing the material - it seems pretty much NewAge Judaism to me - mixing the comfort of remembered traditions with the feel good-ism of liberal politics and PC social world views..... sigh - another sign of the times......

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 02:21 PM
The very basis of New Age is that man is G-d. If this movement edified that type of thought, I'd agree with you. However, from what I have seen of it, all I see (so far) is a mixture of emotions (yes, our G-d is emotional, as well we are emotional beings... this does not indicate 'new age' theology), tradition, the arts, and worship.


NEW AGE DEFINITION

Because the New Age (http://www.watchman.org/cat95.htm#New Age) is simply an umbrella term which covers a myriad of groups, with scores of authors, it is impossible to identify all its doctrines.

The following, however, is a brief overview of the basic teachings of the majority of the New Age groups.

1) All is one: all reality is a unitary whole;

2) Everything is God (god) and God (god) is everything;

3) You (as an individual) are God. You are divine; God is within you;

4) You will never die; You have lived before and you will live again (reincarnation);

5) You can create your own reality or transform your own consciousness;

6) All religions are true and, therefore, one;

7) A new world is coming; a New Age is dawning.I see none of this in Jewish Renewal movements. I see a modern reflection of Judaism. I would, however, allow one to argue that Judaism does not need to 'evolve' (of sorts) but I don't think this even comes close to New Age.

shalom,
yafet

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 02:22 PM
Could this in any way, shape or form be construed as an 'ecumenical' type of effort for Judaism?
I would say no.

muffler dragon
24th June 2004, 02:41 PM
I would say no.
Good deal. Anxiety alleviated.

iitb
24th June 2004, 02:49 PM
I was going to ask for a definition of Reconstructionist Judaism, but figured I should check the FAQ first. ;) Sure enough
Reconstructionist
Reconstructionist Jews are very liberal and do not follow the written Torah. They may practice a few random 'oral torah' laws in their cultural expression of Judaism. They do not necessarily even believe in the existence of G-d. An example of how Reconstructionist Judaism is that they would allow a Lesbian woman to be the Rabbi.
Based on their website, I'd say that the center in Boulder is probably closer to this than anything else. Too bad, 'cause I'd definitely like to check out the Chassidic version!

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 03:51 PM
haha, I think I wrote that ;)

The first person who told me about the Renewal movement was a Chassidic Rabbi. He called it the new Chassidim... or the Neo-Chassidic movement. Since then, I've seen nearly every brand of MJ'ism picking up on this 'renewing'.


I thought it might be a worthy topic as it might even hit MJ'ism, if not already in part.

iitb
24th June 2004, 03:54 PM
Since then, I've seen nearly every brand of MJ'ism picking up on this 'renewing'.
I assume you meant "nearly every brand of Judaism...." ;)

iitb
24th June 2004, 03:56 PM
From what I can tell, it seems almost like the Jewish equivalent of the Charismatic Movement.

Henaynei
24th June 2004, 04:12 PM
The very basis of New Age is that man is G-d. If this movement edified that type of thought, I'd agree with you. However, from what I have seen of it, all I see (so far) is a mixture of emotions (yes, our G-d is emotional, as well we are emotional beings... this does not indicate 'new age' theology), tradition, the arts, and worship.

I see none of this in Jewish Renewal movements. I see a modern reflection of Judaism. I would, however, allow one to argue that Judaism does not need to 'evolve' (of sorts) but I don't think this even comes close to New Age.

shalom,
yafet The NewAge is not nearly as monolithic as this - and many of these are fallacies in practice or application (*never* accept your enemy's own defination of who he is or what his true intentions are). The NewAge has effectively saturated the Christian Body, and MOST effectively in the Charismatic Movement, with it's self-deception and the vast majority are deaf and blind to its presence. The Jewish Observant Body is not immune to the same corruption and deception, sad to say.

I have been watching the NewAge eat the guts out of the Christian Body for longer than you have been alive, most of you anyway, and I tell you this has NewAge written all over it. The alarms are going off, not sirens yet, true, but alarms nonetheless.

"nough said" - I am not articulate enough to prove or convince you...... tread gingerly, I beg you.

b'Shalom
Henaynei

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 04:25 PM
Henaynei,

I appreciate your intesity... I do. But I have studied world religions quite extensively (I have a degree in ancient philosophy, etc) and this is not New Age. I do not denounce your wisdom that your age brings you, but this is something I'm also quite intimately familiar with aside from study. I haven't shared my 'testimony' to everyone here for a few reasons... mostly because I'm still 'evolving' and I'd hate to give half a testimony (hehe... one that's still coming to pass so to speak). But I was quite involved in various cults and New Age when I was younger and I can sniff it a mile away. In no way does Jewish Renewal smell of New Age. The very basis of New Age states man is G-d. Jewish Renewal, while maybe a bit too 'modern' for the old fogies ;), maintains the very foundational Jewish principles that are established in the Torah.

I'm sure that something has risen your 'red flag', and if you can put your finger on it, please share.

One thing that has always caught my eye with Judaism is the focus on society and the arts. I personally enjoy seeing a movement that incorporates the arts into its worship. I find creative expression a beautiful thing, and that's pretty much all that Jewish Renewal is all about. It isn't about speaking in tongues, or anything to do with the 'spirit' taking over... its more about sharing the artistic gifts G-d has given in a worship setting.... whether it be playing the cello or interpretive Davidic dance. In fact, most of the Jewish Renewal centers will hold your average traditional Shabbat services while holding a more expressive and creative (mostly reaching out to youth, etc) at some other time during the week.

Again, if you do discover what it is that has your red flag going up, point it out. All I can really say at this point is that you're quite mistaken about it resembling New Age theology, etc. :( It has nothing to do with making man as though he were G-d. It has everything to do with being creative in our worship.

shalom,
yafet

Henaynei
24th June 2004, 04:25 PM
Could this in any way, shape or form be construed as an 'ecumenical' type of effort for Judaism?

I have my reservations about such in christianity, and I wasn't sure if this might follow along the same path.

NathanIMHO

Neither this or any other form of Judiasm is about "gathering in the gentiles" or an ecumenical bonding with the Chiristians BUT............

If you re-read their own definations, this "Jewish Renewal" is to the Jewish community what the "Ecumenical renewal movement" is to the Christian community. It is that same broad based leveling of compromises and orthodoxy of standards to allow "spiritual unity" between all spectrums of observance and obedience - from Humanistic and reform to Orthodox and Khasidic. It is "All One" canted in Hebrew.

visionary
24th June 2004, 04:33 PM
New Age akin to Universalist????

http://www.network54.com/Forum/201262

This group is a Messianic Judiasm with a Universalist faith.

simchat_torah
24th June 2004, 05:49 PM
oy, that site is ugly.

Visionary... I officially ban you from posting another website that ugly ;)

Shamash Of Yeshua
2nd July 2004, 02:55 AM
oy, that site is ugly.

Visionary... I officially ban:banned: you from posting another website that ugly ;)
:eek:

visionary
2nd July 2004, 08:23 AM
oy, that site is ugly.

Visionary... I officially ban you from posting another website that ugly ;)
What you talking about?????
Ugly.....Are you talking about BRI?

Shamash Of Yeshua
2nd July 2004, 06:57 PM
What you talking about?????
Ugly.....Are you talking about BRI?
Look to the right side of one of your posts and look at the cat... Now think of me with that look upon me. ^_^ :clap: ;)
May HaShem who is called The Most High Elohim by the Name YHWH Bless you with what you need in your life,
Shalom and Shalom,

Tag

simchat_torah
11th November 2004, 03:27 AM
In our conversion class last week our Rabbi discussed the Jewish Renewal movement. I had nearly forgotten about what I previously looked into until he mentioned it. He said that he was very familiar with the Chabad Rebbe who started the movement. Many are leary of new traditions. However, the orthodox movement looks upon this new movement with interest as it is drawing in young crowds by the handfuls.

There was a period in which the renewal movement was seemingly moving into a reform direction until (I forget his name at the moment) the editor of Tikkun magazine became a leading rabbi in the movement. Since this Rabbi has been engrafted into the leadership of this movement, it seems to be finding firmer ground in chabad/orthodox type of expression... while maintaining its artistic expression of worship.

-yafet

Talmidah
11th November 2004, 05:22 AM
There was a period in which the renewal movement was seemingly moving into a reform direction until (I forget his name at the moment) the editor of Tikkun magazine became a leading rabbi in the movement.
Michael Lerner

simchat_torah
11th November 2004, 06:14 AM
yeah, that's the dude.