PDA

View Full Version : Book of Jonah need help


inhimitrust
19th May 2004, 01:42 PM
Book of Jonah


Jonah "dove". Has anyone studied the book of Jonah? I assume there are some bible readers here who might know if what I see in this book could be correct or not.

Jonah appears to represent the whole new testament in one book and is mentioned by Christ "sign of Jonah" in the gosples.
I believe Jonah represents "Christ" in the first part. He is told to preach to Nineveh but runs and boards a "ship". I belive this ship signifies "Jerusalem". The "sailors" appear to represent the "jews"/"romans", he is thrown overboard (crucified), thrown up 3 days later("resurrected"), and turns into "Paul" to preach to the gentiles and I believe Paul was the one that would bind "Peter" and take him where he didn't want to go, as Paul preached against the "old law" which Christ didn't. Christ said He had many more things to say but that was not the time, so of course, Paul comes along to take over).
At the end of Jonah, the vine that grows appears to be "Jerusalem", the worm seems to represent the corrupt jewish priest/rulers, and a scorching "east wind" appears to be the destruction of it.
It was pretty amazing when I was reading thru this for the 7th time and it suddenly just appeared like this. And actually, this may be the only OT scripture that proves Paul coming, as I hear a lot of people saying he was a false apostle or anti semetic. Some messianic jews even try to bring "jews" to Christ by throwing out all of Paul's epistles because they don't agree with what Christ preached. That is a pretty absurd thing to do, as if you discredit even one book in the bible, you discredit the whole bible.
Anyway, this is just a shortened version of my interpretation of this book, and I would like to hear from others on this just for discussion.

thirsty
19th May 2004, 01:53 PM
Book of Jonah


Jonah "dove". Has anyone studied the book of Jonah? I assume there are some bible readers here who might know if what I see in this book could be correct or not.

Jonah appears to represent the whole new testament in one book and is mentioned by Christ "sign of Jonah" in the gosples.
I believe Jonah represents "Christ" in the first part. He is told to preach to Nineveh but runs and boards a "ship". I belive this ship signifies "Jerusalem". The "sailors" appear to represent the "jews"/"romans", he is thrown overboard (crucified), thrown up 3 days later("resurrected"), and turns into "Paul" to preach to the gentiles and I believe Paul was the one that would bind "Peter" and take him where he didn't want to go, as Paul preached against the "old law" which Christ didn't. Christ said He had many more things to say but that was not the time, so of course, Paul comes along to take over).
At the end of Jonah, the vine that grows appears to be "Jerusalem", the worm seems to represent the corrupt jewish priest/rulers, and a scorching "east wind" appears to be the destruction of it.
It was pretty amazing when I was reading thru this for the 7th time and it suddenly just appeared like this. And actually, this may be the only OT scripture that proves Paul coming, as I hear a lot of people saying he was a false apostle or anti semetic. Some messianic jews even try to bring "jews" to Christ by throwing out all of Paul's epistles because they don't agree with what Christ preached. That is a pretty absurd thing to do, as if you discredit even one book in the bible, you discredit the whole bible.
Anyway, this is just a shortened version of my interpretation of this book, and I would like to hear from others on this just for discussion.

It did not take me long to see a flaw in your interpretation of Jonah.
You say that Jonah represented Christ and Jonah disobeyed God. How can that be. Christ never disobeyed the Father. How could He, He was God in the flesh. Jonah disobeyed God because he was afraid of going to Ninevah because the people there were wicked. Christ was afraid of no man. He willing gave Himself up in the garden to be beaten and hung on a cross.

suzie
19th May 2004, 04:03 PM
You also seem to equate Christ with Paul. While God used Paul greatly to bring the Good News to the gentiles, he was not God.

inhimitrust
19th May 2004, 05:46 PM
You also seem to equate Christ with Paul. While God used Paul greatly to bring the Good News to the gentiles, he was not God.HUH? Neither Christ nor Paul were God. So what is your interpretation of it? What would be a good explaination why Jonah is running from God? I haven't really figured that out yet. Am open to ideas though.

thirsty
19th May 2004, 05:52 PM
How do you come up with the idea that Jonah turned in Paul? Jonah was around a long time before Paul.

inhimitrust
19th May 2004, 05:56 PM
Umm it is figuratively symbolic, like most of the rest of the prophets. So someone give me their interpretation once they disprove what this prophecy means, please.

thirsty
19th May 2004, 07:53 PM
It did not take me long to see a flaw in your interpretation of Jonah.
You say that Jonah represented Christ and Jonah disobeyed God. How can that be. Christ never disobeyed the Father. How could He, He was God in the flesh. Jonah disobeyed God because he was afraid of going to Ninevah because the people there were wicked. Christ was afraid of no man. He willing gave Himself up in the garden to be beaten and hung on a cross.
Your theory was disproved with this statement.

suzie
19th May 2004, 08:30 PM
Christ is God. God the Son.

Caoimhin
20th May 2004, 11:15 PM
yeah, you still have to get around that whole thing that Jesus never did run from anything. Also, Jesus lived in Galilee, not Judah, so him going to Jerusalem would be a better parallel with Jonah finally going to Ninevah, not with his refusal to go to Ninevah.

The only possible parallel with Jesus and Jonah, I think (this can be doubted because I'm not very sure on if this parallels with Jesus or not), that when Jonah goes into the belly of the whale he cries "out of the belly of Sheol" (2:2 NRSV) and "Sheol" was, in old Jewish thought, to be a land of the dead, kind of like present day hell. A book I read in the fall semester tried to make a possible comparison with this and Jesus going to hell (I think it's called Sheol in the NRSV, but I can't remember the passage in the NT) while he was in the tomb. It's a pretty shaky comparison, but it's been brought up.

Other than that, I really can't think of any other comparisons.